Her. Beth. Judge Beth Bloom.
I have been around a while, and I have yet to hear of a female judge who rules by following precedent more than her own vague notions of who should "win" by whatever excuses she can concoct at the moment. They get some right from time to time, but overall, I have yet to follow one that I can consistently respect for their jurisprudence.
(However, I believe that she was correct in the Broward County school shooting ruling. There is no duty to defend, no matter how "nice" it sounds or how much we wish to pretend that it is so.)
Scotus ruled there is no duty to defend. She just ruled the way scotus did. Her ruling wouldve gotten overturned.
And there isnt. But at thesame time then they shouldnt demand people disarm themselves either.