Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: BroJoeK

Words are just words. I prefer to look and compare the maps, both Russian MOD, Ukie zmOD, and Western. Both are close, the only problem with the western maps is they “ lag”, ie, the western maps failed to show the fall of Soledar for 5-7 days.

Dima on You Tube - the Military Summary Channel is best, using both maps, BUT he monitors in theatre channels, news, reports , video, they confirm much- all that the west ignores.

As stated , we can see Bakmut is all but steamrolled, Avidivka next, high Russian priority to stop the Ukie artillery that has shelled Donetsk since 2015.

Live video from the Russian social sites now show a huge increase of “ Odessa Next” banners popping up all across the Federation….no loss of resolve from the Russian population, no matter what the corrupted western MSM will have you believe.

Russia does rightly view this war as a war with NATO and the West. That fact alone points to Russia accomplishing its goals, bankrupting the collective West, dividing and bleeding them White.


42 posted on 04/07/2023 5:08:17 PM PDT by delta7
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | View Replies ]


To: delta7; ansel12
delta7: "Words are just words.
I prefer to look and compare the maps, both Russian MOD, Ukie zmOD, and Western.
Both are close, the only problem with the western maps is they “ lag”, ie, the western maps failed to show the fall of Soledar for 5-7 days."

I'd be near certain you'd see that same "lag" on the Russian side when it came to their retreats from Kiev, Kharkiv and Kherson.
But I'm not certain that the exact position of trench lines, which don't change much in weeks or months, is all that critical.
What would be highly important are numbers -- of troops, weapons & casualties -- on both sides but, of course, we will never know those reliably until it becomes history, as opposed to current events.

delta7: "As stated , we can see Bakmut is all but steamrolled, Avidivka next, high Russian priority to stop the Ukie artillery that has shelled Donetsk since 2015."

It's curious, isn't it, how a propagandist will often use his own worst crimes to accuse his opponents of those very crimes?

delta7: "Live video from the Russian social sites now show a huge increase of “ Odessa Next” banners popping up all across the Federation….no loss of resolve from the Russian population, no matter what the corrupted western MSM will have you believe."

So, let's see... if it's true that Russians are wildly enthusiastic about invading and destroying Ukraine, then is it untrue, right? that:

  1. Circa 250,000 Russians have fled from Russia to avoid being drafted in Russia's military?

  2. Russia is having to recruit prisoners to serve as cannon-fodder on the front lines in Ukraine?

  3. Russia arrested a Wall Street Journal reporter for telling the truth about the sad state of Russia's economy?

  4. Russia has lost circa 175,000 soldiers to death or injury, plus over 20,000 military vehicles, from planes & helicopters to tanks, APVs and artillery systems?

  5. Something like 80% of Russia's available army is in or being cycled through Ukraine?
delta7: "Russia does rightly view this war as a war with NATO and the West.
That fact alone points to Russia accomplishing its goals, bankrupting the collective West, dividing and bleeding them White."

Oh, really? That's pretty amazing, when you consider that:

  1. Russia's population is around 146 million, of whom roughly 100 million are actual Russians.
    Russia's GDP is most optimistically (meaning by PPP) put at $5 trillion.

  2. The US population is circa 340 million, of whom nearly all are Americans.
    Our GDP is around $25 trillion, by either nominal or PPP.

  3. The 28 member European Union population is around 450 million, of whom most all are Europeans.
    Europe's GDP is circa $21 trillion (PPP)

  4. Our six Pacific Rim allies (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Philippines, Australia and Canada) total about 370 million population, with GDPs totaling $16 trillion.

So let's add them up: Russia 146 million people, maybe $5 trillion GDP.

US and our allies: 1.152 billion people, $63 trillion in GDP.
So, we outnumber Russians eight to one in populations and twelve to one in GDPs.
So who, exactly, do you think is going to bleed whom dry?

Oh? So now you spring your BIG SURPRISE on us -- the Xi-snake's China will turn the balance of power in Russia's favor, right?

Well... Russia and China together have 1.558 billion people with $35 trillion in PPP GDP.
So, now it's a closer match, though US/Allies GDP is still 80% more than China/Russia according to PPP estimates.
If we go by nominal numbers, then we are three times the combined China/Russia GDP.

And if China/Russia do become dominant, then what will happen with other large countries which today try to remain neutral & friendly to all?

  1. India 1.4 billion people, $ 11.7 trillion GDP
  2. Indonesia 275 million people, $ 4.0 trillion GDP
  3. Pakistan 236 million people, $ 1.5 trillion GDP
  4. Mexico 129 million people, $2.9 trillion GDP
  5. Turkey 85 million people, $3.3 trillion GDP

    Total of major "neutral" countries: 2.137 billion people, $23.4 trillion GDP.

Of those, India often supports Russia out of fear of China, but if China and Russia are allied, perhaps India will need new allies?

Plus there's this -- in addition to the US allies we'd expect to support Ukraine, there are at least ten others, perhaps surprising supporters of Ukraine, in alphabetical order:

  1. Azerbaijan
  2. Cambodia
  3. Columbia
  4. Iceland
  5. Israel
  6. Morocco
  7. New Zealand
  8. Pakistan
  9. Sudan
  10. Turkey
In that sense, arguably Ukraine is already a World War, even though there've been no battles yet outside the immediate theater of war.

This map shows how each country responded to the war in Ukraine.

49 posted on 04/08/2023 1:06:21 PM PDT by BroJoeK (future DDG 134 -- we remember)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson