Posted on 07/21/2023 11:22:24 PM PDT by AmericaFirst101
With no significant breakthrough after six weeks, it is worth asking whether Ukraine’s counter-offensive can ever succeed, for it certainly doesn’t look to be succeeding now.
(clip)
The question to be asked is: are the Ukrainians prepared – militarily, politically, financially – to carry out months and potentially years of these (frontal assault) attacks to penetrate 1914-18 style defensive belts of tank traps, barbed wire, minefields, bunkers and trench lines? The UK Ministry of Defence has described these Russian fortifications as “some of the most extensive systems of military defensive works seen anywhere in the world”.
(clip)
Ukraine is already outnumbered in every military capability. Its dire shortage of armoured vehicles means that Kyiv is approaching this counter-offensive with immense caution. Many Nato-supplied tanks and infantry fighting vehicles were knocked out during early probing attacks and they are consequently holding most of the rest of these assets back to avoid too many more losses. That is understandable – yet only a bold, concerted assault with massed armour is likely to overcome the Russians.
(Excerpt) Read more at telegraph.co.uk ...
The concept of Ukraine launching frontal assaults against heavily defended positions, particularly a series of assaults over months or years as Kemp suggests, seems remote at best.
The Ukrainian troops, brave and willing though they have been, know they are out-gunned. The Ukrainian forces have launched their counter-offensive with virtually no success but at high cost of life and materiel.
For now, it seems, Ukraine looks to be running out of time and running out of options. Sending more waves of troops to be cut down by Russian defenses probably won't alter the equation. It likely would just lower Ukraine morale even further.
The most telling part of this article, I think, is that Kemp and other NATO supporters are finally starting to tell the truth about things on the ground in Ukraine. The counter-offensive is not working, it's unclear if it will ever/could ever work, and Russia is fully dug in now, unlike last fall.
At some point, in my opinion, there comes a time to think about the lives of the foreign troops you are using as canon fodder on a chessboard. Particularly when "victory" seems a far, far ways away.
30 seconds over Putin’s Dacha seems like the only proposal.
30 seconds over Putin’s Dacha seems like the only proposal.
Whose air force is going to do that? Not the USA I hope.
The gaslighting continues.
Sounds like Ron DeSantis’s campaign.
The fact that this “war” has gone on as long as it has is proof positive that the military industrial complex is perpetuating it.
The BiXiden Crime family, Linda Grahmnasty and Pierre Delecto likely benefit.
Putin knows he can’t be kicked out of Ukraine until NATO commits to total air dominance. Such a program would be very costly for NATO in terms of pilots, planes and political capitol. The Russian air defenses are not pushovers, the Russians have the planes to make a fight in the air, and the Russians would be able to resupply at least in the early stages, before total dominance is achieved, if it ever is.
The Russian response to NATO entering the air war would probably be more surprising yet logical than I can imagine. I’m sure whatever it is would be quite costly to the West in some manner or another.
*******************************************
After six weeks Ukraine has had 26,000 soldiers killed and hasn't gotten within miles of the first line of the real Russian defenses, of which there are three.
This counteroffensive was a totally predictable massive flop. It will only accelerate Ukraine's collapse.
Ukraine is outmanned, outgunned, and doesn’t have air superiority. A counteroffensive with these facts is foolish.
I expect the Russians to wait until the Ukes expend the last of their reserves on this foolish frontal attack and then launch a massive counter offensive. They have way more troops. They’ve been holding them back to this point.
I don’t think the air superiority matters because Russians are not going to get it either.
The author says that the key to breakthrough is “demining kit to clear paths through enemy obstacles, cluster munitions and ATACM long-range missiles”
At least Congress passed the bill to send Ukraine cluster munitions and I really don’t understand why Biden is holding back ATACMS even after both Brits and French have sent Storm Shadow/SCALP.
The fact that this “war” has gone on as long as it has is proof positive that the military industrial complex is perpetuating it.
and Zelenskyy has informed Joey B of his deep knowledge of where the Biden bodies are buried —and documented —in corrupt Ukrainian politics.
I thought Moscow was about to fall!
Was I lied to!?
“After the failure of sanctions against Russia, the US State Department and this clueless administration had no Plan B, except “Whatever it takes, as long it takes,” a pointless mission statement I heard repeated about a hundred times.”
Isn’t cutting off our own oil production helping to keep the price off oil high and helping to fund Russia who gets a lot of their revenue from oil?
Minor issue.. Biden will give another $100 billion and Europe will chip in $5.00 or $10.00 bucks.
F’em all.
Bidenskyyyyy needs to send Caramela Harris over there to teach the Russkis that war is bad. She’s the giggling expert they need to hear.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.