There are two issues: Israel itself and Israel in its relationship to the US.
I believe the US should have a cordial relationship with Israel. I don't believe we should meddle in their internal affairs. I don't believe we should give them money like clockwork, and I don't believe the Israeli government should expect its spies in the US to receive special treatment.
I think Israel, in the palaeoconservative analysis, is as muddled as the US. It is at once a socialist Eurostate and the home of a deeply religious people yearning for a benevolent theocracy. That state of affairs cannot continue forever, just as the US cannot waver forever between being a socialist Eurostate and a Constitutional republic. I am fundamentally ambivalent toward Israel for this reason, just as I am fundamentally ambivalent about the direction our country is headed.
That being said, I support the Jewish people settling in their ancestral homelands and I support all efforts by the US to rid this land of Islamist terror and to destroy it wherever found. I consider Islam to be an ideology eerily dissimilar from Communism or Nazism.