Skip to comments.Happy Holidays? Bah! Humbug!
Posted on 11/24/2001 2:49:30 PM PST by ouroboros
In 1938, Whittaker Chambers broke with the Communist Party. In Witness, Chambers describes his Christmas that year as one of great joy, in which he first told his children the Christmas story, shared with them the Christmas ornaments that had decorated his childhood Christmas trees, and enjoyed the Christmas carols his daughter was then learning.
At first glance, it is surprising that Christmas 1938 should have meant anything to the Chambers family. After all, Chambers was not yet a Christian, and his wife had never been a Christian. Yet such was the splendor of Christmas as once celebrated in America that Chambers had felt its pull even when he was still a Communist. Chambers remembered that Christmas had always been our one great holiday when I was a boy, and, as a Party member, he introduced his family to as much of the Christmas celebration as the Party permitted.
A contemporary of Chambers, Fr. Gereon Goldmann, experienced a very different Christmas half a world away. As a conscript in the SS, Goldmann was forced to celebrate not Christmas, but a bizarre winter holiday concocted by the Nazis:
"On Christmas Eve, there was a celebration, not a Christian one, but a pagan German Julfest. We were all together and had to sing some trash about the night of the clear stars and other sad substitutes for the true Christmas message."
As shocking as it may sound, the contemporary public observance of Christmas in America bears a much closer resemblance to the Nazis Julfest than to the Christmas that enticed Chambers. And this extraordinary transformation has occurred in a generation.
I was born in 1964. Of course, my memories of my family Christmases are warm ones. But I also fondly remember the public celebrations of Christmas. In my public elementary school, we made Christmas ornaments and Christmas cards, sang Christmas carols, and ate Christmas cookies. In junior high, our Christmas concert introduced me to more wonderful Christmas music, including a portion of Bachs Christmas Oratorio and Pietro Yons Gesu Bambino. Merry Christmas was a universal greeting, Christmas carolers were regular visitors in our neighborhood, and the profusion of decorations adorning all manner of stores left no doubt as to what holiday everyone was celebrating. Local radio stations would air Christmas music throughout December, and the most popular station in town would air nothing but Christmas music from 6:00 P.M. on Christmas Eve until the end of Christmas Day. Television was filled with Christmas specials, and even the most secular shows almost invariably featured workmanlike and even reverent performances of some hallowed carols.
No one I knew was bothered by the effusive celebration of a national holiday observed by the overwhelming majority of Americans. The only concerns of which I was aware were admonitions against the commercialization of Christmas and to keep Christ in Christmas.
Such concerns now seem quaint. As Don Feder observed last December, Today, the challenge is to keep Christmas in Christmas. We now have holiday cards, holiday parties, holiday songs, and even holiday trees. In order to avoid giving offense to anyone anywhere, millions of Americas are now seemingly content to keep quiet about the holiday they do celebrate and to act as if all sorts of other minor festivalsKwanzaa, Hanukkah, Bodhi Day, Diwali, Ramadan, the winter solsticeare equally important. It has reached the point where wishing someone a Merry Christmas is a political act, not a friendly commonplace. Think about it: When was the last time a store employee, seeing you buying presents on Christmas Eve, wished you a Merry Christmas rather than Happy Holidays? When was the last time you wished a stranger Merry Christmas rather than Happy Holidays?
My first introduction to the anti-Christmas mania that has engulfed America occurred in college. In 1984, a suitemate and I attempted to introduce Christmas cheer to our dormitory by putting up a Christmas tree and a nativity scene. Unfortunately, our suite also housed prospective students visiting the campus, and we were told the crèche had to go, lest a prospective non-Christian student take offense. Apparently, high-school seniors were so delicate that they could not withstand the knowledge that other people might not believe everything they did.
Law school was no better. In 1988, the new dean of the Michigan Law School, Lee Bollinger, issued an edict to the law-school student singing group, the Headnotes, declaring that they could not sing any Christmas music at the schools end-of-semester gathering. This prohibition covered not just religious carols, but any song that even mentioned the word Christmas. (Ironically, Bollingers academic specialty is the First Amendment.) Instead, the law school offered up an absurd, leftist commentary on Antigone set to awful contemporary music. (As a friend remarked, it was beginning to look a lot like Thebes.)
Of course, the desire to suppress Christmas is scarcely confined to higher education. My sisters children until very recently attended a public elementary school in an affluent Detroit suburb. In that suburban system, which has a student body that is overwhelmingly white and (at least nominally) Christian, teachers are forbidden to mention Christmas. Instead, they teach about Hanukkah and Kwanzaa. So thorough was the indoctrination that my nephew asked two years ago why we did not celebrate Hanukkah or Kwanzaa. He knew about Christmas, of course, but was understandably concerned that he was missing out on something, since the only holidays he heard about outside the home were absent from our family celebrations.
Some elementary-school teachers have chosen a less direct assault on Christmas, diminishing its importance by presenting it as merely one of an ever-growing list of seemingly equal and interchangeable holidays rather than obliterating all mention of it. Last year, a friends son participated in his elementary schools holiday concert. In his school system, the great majority of students are white and Christian, yet only two Christmas carols were sung, and one of them was Feliz Navidad. This small concession to Christmas was more than outweighed by the two Kwanzaa songs, the two Hanukkah songs, the Ramadan song, and the Chinese New Year song the children also performed. (I suspect that all the non-Christmas songs are recent concoctions, written for such dreary occasions as contemporary public school winter concerts.)
Another illustration of the multicultural madness came from a friend whose daughter attends public school in another suburb that is overwhelmingly white and Christian. She brought home an exercise designed to help the children learn to tell time. The exercise featured the following holiday schedule for a winter holiday party:
Make Kwanzaa mkekas: 12:00 noon
Make Christmas cookies: 12:30 p.m.
Listen to a story about Ramadan: 1:00 p.m.
Play the dreidel game: 1:30 p.m.
Break a piñata: 2:00 p.m.
Make Diwali powder designs: 2:30 p.m.
Go on a Chinese New Year parade: 3:00 p.m.
The sheer inanity of these examples (and of the countless others that could have been included) is striking. But the most important thing about the transformation of Christmas to holiday is how needless it was, and how it was the product not of tolerance, but of hatred, resentment, and envy.
The transformation was needless because the formerly exuberant American Christmas inflicted real harm on no one, while giving joy to many. Christmas in America was never marked by pogroms or expressions of hatred but by countless acts of charity and kindness. Much of the public celebration of Christmas was capable of being enjoyed by non-Christians as well as Christians, and almost everyone did enjoy at least some of it. I know non-Christians who enjoy Christmas specials, Christmas movies, Christmas music; I do not think these people are unique.
The multiculturalists justify their assault on Christmas by claiming that the public celebration of Christmas causes non-Christians to feel left out. I am skeptical of this claim; I suspect most people are not overwhelmed by the knowledge that others do not always believe as they do. But even if the multiculturalists are right, how much should we worry about those who feel left out by the public celebration of Christmas? We cannot forever shield non-Christians from the reality that they are a minority in America, and suppressing the observances of the majority seems a high price to pay to allow overly sensitive souls to live in a comfortable delusion. Of course, children should not be required to participate in school activities of which their parents disapprove, and local control of schools means that districts with large populations of non-Christians will probably have different December activities than districts that reflect the American norm. But a child who does not participate in a Christmas concert is no more excluded than a child whose parents do not allow him to go on a field trip or take a role in a school play. We do not respond to one form of exclusion by banning field trips or plays; we should not respond to the other by banning Christmas.
The multiculturalists, though, respond to the phony problem of exclusion by trying to ban Christmas because banning Christmas is what they are all about. They are animated by a hatred of Christianity, or of the West, or by sheer envy and resentment of the glories of a holiday they despise. If Christian children benefit from learning about Hanukkah and Kwanzaa and all the rest, shouldnt non-Christian children benefit even more from learning about the holiday most of their countrymen observe? But, of course, the trend has been to load curricula with references to formerly obscure festivals, while assiduously minimizing and even eliminating references to Christmas.
The malice of the multiculturalists is revealed in the way they present the alternative holidays they so evidently prefer. Kwanzaa, Hanukkah, and all the rest are presented as faux-Christmases, even anti-Christmases, in order to compete with, diminish, and ultimately efface Christmas. If Hanukkah customarily fell in October, would anyone other than observant Jews even notice it?
Indeed, the versions of Kwanzaa and Hanukkah now being taught to millions of schoolchildren are fabrications. Kwanzaa, of course, is completely phony, the 1966 invention of black nationalist Maulana Karenga. But Hanukkahs contemporary incarnation is a fabrication, toothe Jewish Kwanzaa, as Frederic Schwarz observed in last Decembers American Heritage magazine. Traditionally, Hanukkah was a very minor festival, primarily for children, overshadowed theologically not only by the High Holy Days and Passover but also by Simchat Torah, Shavuot, and Sukkot, and surpassed by Purim as an occasion for celebration. Teaching children about Kwanzaa, rather than about the Christmas carols and spirituals developed by blacks, inculcates negative lessons about whites instead of positive ones about blacks. Teaching children about Hanukkah, rather than the beliefs that actually sustained Jews on their sometimes tragic and tumultuous historical journey, inculcates negative lessons about Christianity, not positive ones about Judaism.
Nor, despite the multiculturalists claims, are the anti-Christmases even remotely equal to the real thing. In theological terms, Christmas is the second most important feast in the Christian calendar. In practical terms, it has been the principal holiday of the worlds most creative civilization for over a millennium. It has inspired a profusion of art, architecture, literature, and music; a love of Christmas can lead to a deeper love of our whole civilization. Giotto never painted a Kwanzaa scene, Bach did not write a Hanukkah Oratorio, and Dickens did not pen A Ramadan Carol. And no one comparable to them did, either. Ultimately, we should be free to celebrate Christmas publicly and joyously, because it is a great holiday, and because it is our holidayone of the crowning glories of the Western culture that gave birth to America and sustains us still.
Despite the undeniably depressing nature of the continuing and expanding assault against Christmas, I have not lost all hope. Most Americans still cherish Christmas, just as Chambers remembered Christmas with fondness even during his time as a Communist. The truth set Chambers free from Communism, and the truth can set us free from multiculturalism. If we summon the courage to stand up for our beliefs, the words of the carol beloved by Dickens will once more ring true:
Now to the Lord sing praises,
All you within this place,
And with true love and brotherhood,
Each other now embrace.
This holy tide of Christmas,
All others doth deface.
O tidings of comfort and joy,
Comfort and joy.
O tidings of comfort and joy.
Tom Piatak writes from Cleveland, Ohio.
It's a good thing Ramadan floats around the year or we'd have to deal with it as a substitute for Christmas all the time. Ramadan is the only one that compares to Christmas in its importance to the people who practice it.
CHRISTMAS IS A CHRISTIAN HOLIDAY! If the people who want to celebrate it refuse to acknowledge that, then they just want a day off work and a few cheap presents.
Every year we hear that same dull drum. So what? The THEME isn't pagan. The SUBJECT isn't pagan. Okay. It happens to fall on the winter solstice, the Saturnalia, some Druid queen's birthday. The DAY isn't important. But the celebration of the Redeemer's birth IS. And how ashamed He would be if He could see the festival of greed it has become.
I would say the assault comes from within.
The enemy is in the camp.
The Communist multiculturalists in our Congress have promoted their socialist beliefs from the United Nations into our Press, Television, Educational systems, Law Enforcement systems, Supreme Court, Congress, Senate and White House. Christian beliefs surely are anti UN, therefore they will continue to be pushed away from our schools, government, state and national laws. The general population is not aware of this of course because they have been effectively divided and conquered into ethnic groups much more worried about equality and status.
Our President recently gave 585 million taxpayer dollars to the United Nations when just a few months before they kicked us off the United Nations Commission on Human Rights. Instead of America they selected Sudan,(the worlds one country that supports slavery) Uganda, Sierra Leone, and Togo, to a three-year rotating membership. These countries will join Syria, Algeria, Libya, Saudi Arabia, and Vietnam amongst the 53 member Human Rights Commision.
Down in Georgia there is a battle going on about a Judge who has the Ten Commandments on his courtroom walls. How can he possibly decide cases of Muslims or Hindus believing in the Christian religion?
Refugees and immigrants continue to come into the US and apply for welfare, housing, medical care and any other program that is free to them. With hand votes in our Senate, that are meant to keep records from our view, Bills are passed that will guarantee Socialism is our future. It won't be long before the privately own firearms are confiscated and destroyed. Then the New World Odor (Order)will be the only scent in our air.
Happy Holidays to all who just sit back and allow this to happen?. I don't think so.
PATRIOTS are not "Revolutionaries" trying to overthrow the government of the United States.
PATRIOTS are "Counter-Revolutionaries" trying to prevent the government of the United States from overthrowing the Constitution of the United States. - Unknown Author
One Solitary Life
|He was born in an obscure village, the child of a peasant woman. He grew up in another village, where he worked in a carpenter shop until he was thirty. Then for three years he was an itinerant preacher.
He never wrote a book. He never held an office. He never traveled more than two hundred miles from the place where he was born. He did none of the things one usually associates with greatness.
He was only thirty-three when the tide of public opinion turned against him. He was turned over to his enemies and went through the mockery of a trial. He was nailed to a cross between two thieves. When he was dead, he was laid in a borrowed grave.
Nineteen centuries have come and gone, and today he is a central figure of the human race and leader of mankind's progress.
All the armies that ever marched, all the navies that ever sailed, all the kings that ever reigned have not affected the life of man as much as that One Solitary Life - Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
MERRY CHRISTMAS AND PEACE TO MEN OF GOOD WILL
It starts with our own unrepentant sin and goes out from there. I always found the Old Testament [You know, that evil, old, irrelavant set of books ; ) ] to be extremely helpful. Our sinful compromises are the very tools of our discipline. Recognition of that helps see that the Left, liberals, and assorted enemies of the like are here becasue we ain't ready yet to move on. Destroying them is more than just there physical removal...
Something is amiss "in the house."
Judgement begins at the House of the Lord.
They are still trying...
I personally arrange for an old-fashioned caroling party at my house each year. We usually have 40-50 show up. 30 or so tour the neighborhood, while the less hardy stay in the house preparing hot chocolate, spiced cider, cookies, and such.
They'll only erase Christmas if we're too shy to celebrate it. Merry Christmas FR!
The author is misinformed about Kwanzaa.
First, Kwanzaa was not set up to replace Christmas and most blacks who celebrate Kwanzaa also celebrate Christmas. There is simply no need to choose between one or the other unless one wants to.
Second, Kwanzaa does not teach hatred of anyone, but encourages a greater appreciation of black/African culture. Anyone who thinks Kwanzaa encoruages negativity against whites doesn't know what they're talking about.
I have celebrated Kwanzaa for a long time and still plan to do so this year.
I can assure you...He sees EVERYTHING with a clarity far beyond our ability to comprehend.
She cites how Father Rutler, a Catholic priest, gave Final Absolution to scores of firemenn before they went rushing into the WTC.
My point here is that our Christian faith is still as strong as ever, no matter what some academics may want to do in discouraging the celebration of Christmas.
Be of good cheer, and go out there have a wonderful Christmas. God would expect no less!
Merry Christmas to you all!
"MERRY CHRISTMAS AND PEACE TO MEN OF GOOD WILL"
E-S, That bears repetition. Peace and love, George.
Kwanzaa has never been promoted as anything but an African-American non-religious celebration. It is now celebrated in parts of Africa but no one thinks it is African in origin.
The popularity of Kwanzaa is not due to "marketing," so much as it is to the fact that people tried it, liked it, and decided to celebrate it themselves. Its founder cannot control where or how it is celebrated, so if you or anyone else has a problem with it being celebrated in the schools, take it up with your school and/or school board.
I think we just need to realize that what we really have going on are two different "Christmases". The religious Christmas that celebrates the birth of Jesus Christ, and the commercial/social Christmas that is the parties and shopping.
AFAIK virtually every culture in the Northern Hemisphere has engaged in some kind of social celebrations this time of year. Personally I suspect it may be partially driven by the fact that we aren't getting enough sunlight, and we're getting crabby and restless. Somehow we have come to call this social event "Christmas". But it is still just a label, a word, the mutterings of imperfect mortals. True believers will know and understand the difference. Non believers may yet some day, but for the the present, I see no good to be had by cursing them for what they do out of ignorance.
I can only make sure I keep the "Christmases" separate in my life, and while I may celebrate the social Christmas with friends and co-workers, and people I meet on the street, I reserve the celebration of the birth of Jesus to my heart, my home, and my church.
I believe he does. I also believe he must find much of what we mortal fools do rather humorous, even though believing in a God with a sense of humor seems to put me at odds with organized religion frequently.
Overall everything sucks this time of year, and it all starts with some bad clamations featuring awful songs that we had to watch every freaking year (why do parents make their kids watch the specials? the parents know these things suck, if the kid doesn't wanna don't make him). Of course younger people won't understand this. We now live in a world with cable and VCRs, you actually can avoid those awful movies. Not when I was a kid, 3 channels and all of them were showing something lame, and if you said they were awful people called you Scrooge. Have you actually watched this crap?! It is lame.
Now I watch mob movies this time of year, thank God for DVD. Nothing like Joe Pesci swearing like a sailor whose private parts just got shot off and stabbing people with a pen to really clean that awful Christmas time stench out of your brain and leave you ready to remember the important things about Christmas: love and giving, peace and goodwill. There's really nothing like not being forced to endure hours of bad entertainment on the real meaning of Christmas to actually allow you to enjoy the real meaning of Christmas. Do your kids a favor, don't make them watch holiday specials if they don't want to, they might actually grow up to like holidays.
I'd be your biggest fan if you freepmailed me some Goodfellas links. I can always use more .wavs that revolve around the F word. They're so handy to tie to Windows errors.
Well said. The idea of human deprevity and sin is being replaced. Instead of being born in sin and enemies to God, we are told we are A-moral. Now it's we are just plain good. Choosing God when we want and basically running the universe from our autonomous hearts.
I prefer the true Christmas Herald.
Though I was DOA, deserving of Hell and an all around rebel in this Kingdom. I was remade, reborn, adopted and made an heir to the King.
I am eternally grateful for a gift I did not ask for and left to my own "choosing" would have discarded without a thought.
The work of being involved in Church and developing into an Elder with Biblical wisdom is hard work. It's a collision course with not only the culture but pop theology and they ain't gonna sit quietly. The Book of Joshua is great wisdom for fighting the modern day baalism. Secular humanism. And it starts with our own idols.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.