[Fraulein]

Elders insited that no, it's not saying what it is saying.

I guess it all boils down to what the definition of is is.

[ladylib]

It's not saying what it's saying, even though a reasonable person would conclude that it is saying what it's saying. These are the same people who think the Constitution is a "living" document and can be made to say whatever the reader wants it to say.