Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Pius the hero
The Spectator. ^ | 7/20/02 | John Laughland

Posted on 07/23/2002 9:31:27 PM PDT by Valin

Pope Pius XII is once more accused of being lenient towards Hitler. John Laughland meets the man who can prove his innocence

When you visit a senior official in the Vatican, you expect to enter a world of ancient traditions: you do not expect to encounter practices which died out in 1950. Yet when I called on Peter Gumpel, SJ in his office in Borgo Santo Spirito early one morning, his first question was, ‘Would you care for a cigarette?’ A selection of three different brands was produced out of a drawer. ‘Holy smoke!’ I thought, and chose Dunhill. As I puffed my way gently through the morning, a fine rain fell on the orange grove outside.

There are some people in whose presence the heart warms with a peculiar intensity. Father Professor Dr Gumpel is such a man. The high-domed forehead betrays both formidable intelligence and distinguished ancestry; the exquisite manners and the immaculate languages (‘I had to give this lecture in Latin because I do not speak Polish’) are the unmistakable hallmarks of the German ancien régime. Yet this frail, softly spoken man is in the eye of a storm.

Gumpel is a historian whose job is to write reports on whether people qualify for sainthood. He is working on the cause of Eugenio Pacelli, Pope Pius XII, whom people keep accusing of not doing enough to save Jews during the second world war. Only last week, a fictional film, Amen, opened in London, trotting out the same tired and discredited accusations. Last year Fr Gumpel was asked to assist the work of a Catholic–Jewish historical commission constituted to examine Vatican documents on the matter. For various reasons, this commission collapsed in mutual recriminations last August, and Gumpel was instructed by the Pope to issue a sharp statement accusing the Jewish historians of professional misconduct, of bad faith and, effectively, of lying. ‘The whole experience was shattering,’ says Gumpel.

As it happens, Fr Gumpel is not only an academic expert on this period: he was also a first-hand witness of it. Now aged 78, he remembers as a boy of ten watching his grandfather, a close personal friend of Field Marshal Hindenburg, turn white with anger when he heard that the German president had appointed Hitler chancellor. ‘Hindenburg promised me he would never do this!’ said the grandfather. The old man and one of Gumpel’s cousins were subsequently shot by the Nazis, and the same fate would have befallen Gumpel and his mother if the Nazis had caught them hiding a former socialist minister in their apartment near the Kurfürstendamm.

Gumpel has to draw on his considerable priestly qualities to suppress his obvious inner anger when people today attack Pius XII. As a student in the Netherlands during the war, Gumpel himself heard the Bishop of Utrecht read out the famous protest against deportations made in all Dutch Catholic churches in 1942. Protestant pastors withdrew from what had been an all-Christian initiative after the Gestapo announced that they would deport baptised Jews if the declaration was made. Gumpel has now tracked down a speech given on 3 August 1942 by Governor Seyss-Inquart’s deputy, General-Kommissar Schmidt, in which he said that, because of the Catholic Church’s obstinacy, ‘we are forced to consider Catholics of Jewish race our worst enemy and, for this reason, to deport them to the East as quickly as possible’. In other words, careless talk cost lives.

This event caused Pope Pius to devote himself to secret acts to help the Jews. Before that, he had issued scores of public denunciations of Nazi racism, as papal nuncio in Bavaria, as secretary of state under Pius XI, and as Pope: for his opposition to Hitler, he was lampooned in the Nazi press as a friend of the Jews and as a Jew himself. His secret efforts were heroic. Throughout the 1940s and 1950s, Pius XII was the object of adulation by Jews and Gentiles alike because of the Catholic Church’s role in saving more than 700,000 Jewish lives. As Rabbi David Dalin has shown, the people who showered official and public praise on Pius XII include Albert Einstein in 1940; Chaim Weizmann in 1943; the Chief Rabbi of Israel in 1944; the secretary of the World Jewish Congress in 1945; Moshe Sharett, Israel’s second prime minister, in 1945; the Union of Italian Jewish Communities in 1955; the State of Israel via the Israeli Philharmonic Orchestra, which gave a special concert for the Pope in the Vatican in 1955; and Golda Meir on his death in 1958. The Chief Rabbi of Rome, Israel Zolli, converted to Catholicism in 1944 and took the Christian name Eugenio in recognition of the Pope’s personal record in saving Jews.

Jewish historians and experts have followed suit in their praise of Pius: the list of his defenders includes Sir Martin Gilbert and the former deputy chief US prosecutor at Nuremberg, Robert Kempner. A brilliant lawyer of German Jewish origin, Kempner wrote a preface and epilogue to Jenö Levai’s 1968 book on Hungarian Jewry and the Papacy: Pope Pius XII Did Not Remain Silent, in which he says that the book ‘depicts truthfully the part played by the Catholic Church in the struggle against the “Final Solution of the Jewish question in Hungary”’. Kempner denounced ‘a deliberately fabricated myth’ that the Church had remained silent and done nothing — a myth he equates with pro-Nazi revisionism because it attempts to displace blame for the Holocaust from the Nazis on to the Catholic Church.

This unanimously favourable view of Pius XII was singlehandedly overturned in 1963. The cause was not a new piece of historical research but instead a fictional play by a former member of the Hitler Youth, Rolf Hochhuth. The Deputy has been reissued this year as the film entitled Amen by Constantin Costa-Gavras. Both use invented characters to accuse the Pope of not speaking out strongly enough and of being lenient towards Hitler. The result has been staggering: nine books on Pius XII have been published in the last year and a half. Yet, according to Fr Gumpel, ‘This is not a Jewish–Catholic argument.’ Indeed, Rabbi Dalin accuses three of Pius’s attackers, two former seminarians and a former priest, of using their accusations to conduct an internal argument within the Catholic Church about the future of the Papacy after John Paul II.

Perhaps the reason why these charges against Pius XII are so infectious is that they are constructed in such a way that they cannot be disproved. They are what Karl Popper called an unfalsifiable proposition: however many public attacks on Nazism Pius XII did make, one can always say he should have made more. Moreover, the denunciations of Pius today, unlike his own ones of Nazism, are cost-free: unlike Pius’s decisions, on which the lives of millions depended, today’s attacks on him produce a nice pharisaical glow of moral superiority, not to mention extremely profitable book sales. ‘It was a question of great anguish for Pius,’ says Fr Gumpel, ‘but he knew from bitter experience that direct statements produced terrible results.’

The historical commission now lies in ruins and Catholic–Jewish relations in acrimony. The Vatican stands accused of not opening its archives, even though the commission members did not even bother to read all of the 8,000 pages of documents that were put at their disposal, and even though the Vatican’s wartime papers lie uncatalogued in hundreds of boxes. ‘No archive in the world allows access to uncatalogued papers,’ says Gumpel. ‘Moreover,’ — and here he pauses, perhaps for effect — ‘every sovereign entity has rules of disclosure. I have myself tried to obtain American documents about the transfer to the United States of German scientists who worked for the Nazis. Every single one I requested has been removed.’ Point taken. As we stand up at the end of our meeting, Fr Gumpel returns to his other favourite theme. ‘Are you sure you have enough cigarettes?’ he asks. ‘Take some.’

© 2002 The

TOPICS: Culture/Society; Extended News
KEYWORDS: catholiclist; hitler; holocaust; popepiusxii
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-33 next last

1 posted on 07/23/2002 9:31:27 PM PDT by Valin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: *Catholic_list
2 posted on 07/23/2002 9:37:24 PM PDT by Valin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin
Pope Pius XII opposed the creation of a Jewish state in it's biblical homeland goven to them by God. Even after the horrors of the Jewish Holocaust, Pius strongly opposed the creation of the state of Israel.

Here is the link to prove it.>>>>>>>

He also knowingly and willingly signed his name on the dotted line next to Adolph Hitler's name on their concordat. (Did Pius pray to God for guidance before doing that?)

No amount of spin will ever overcome the historical damnation of Pius the twelfth.

3 posted on 07/23/2002 9:45:12 PM PDT by berned
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: GOP_Thug_Mom; denimjumpermom; LarryLied; sfousa
4 posted on 07/23/2002 9:46:29 PM PDT by pax_et_bonum
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin
Nice article. Thanks for posting.
5 posted on 07/23/2002 9:48:49 PM PDT by pax_et_bonum
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Valin
6 posted on 07/23/2002 9:49:11 PM PDT by patton
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: berned
Pius strongly opposed the creation of the state of Israel.


7 posted on 07/23/2002 10:03:30 PM PDT by Aliska
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: patent
8 posted on 07/23/2002 10:17:44 PM PDT by Rightwing Canuck
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Aliska

Well, Aliska, I certainly have my theories as to why the Vatican appears to hate Israel. When you look from The Inquisition, to their coziness with Hitler during the Holocaust, to their opposition to the creation of national Israel after the Holocaust, to TODAY -- where the Vatican sides with Arafat and the Palestinians over God's people Israel, I see a clear, unrelenting and undeniable pattern of anti-semitism coming from the Vatican.

As to motive, my thoughts are too controversial for this forum.

9 posted on 07/23/2002 10:19:04 PM PDT by berned
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: berned
10 posted on 07/23/2002 10:20:47 PM PDT by weikel
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: berned
i'm eating a cold pork chop and it's time to quit for the night. maybe it doesn't have anything to do with anti-semitism. maybe it was premature. it sure complicated things in the middle east. maybe we should have given them connecticut.

i need to further research this topic.

i'm not a big apologist for pius x was it? he had to walk on eggs much like gwb has to today. it's pragmatism, not necessarily anti-semitism.

11 posted on 07/23/2002 10:32:52 PM PDT by Aliska
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Aliska
Cold pork chops before bedtime can't be good for you, can it? :-) You might have nightmares of Janet Reno dancing with Rosie O'Donell, or something equally scary!
12 posted on 07/23/2002 10:50:05 PM PDT by berned
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: berned; Romulus
You claim that the Vatican hates Israel. Part of your proof posted on this thread is the concordat signed with Germany. You should be aware the Vatican also has signed agreements with Israel. It is hardly unusual. In any case, you are full of it.


13 posted on 07/23/2002 10:56:53 PM PDT by patent
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: patent; berned
I agree with you patent. I don't know what your beef with the Vatican is berned, but the Catholic Church was persecuted by Nazi Germany, since it resisted attempts by Hitler's henchmen to "Nazify" it, along with other German churches. Millions of Catholic Poles were butchered too. I saw a book titled "The Persecution of the Catholic Church in the Third Reich" on the Conservative Book Club's website. The headline for their advertisement was "THE BIG LIE: Two popes were "silent" about the evils of Nazism." Here's the CBC's description of the book:

In just the past few years, half a dozen books, all from major publishers, have claimed that the wartime popes, Vatican officials, and the German hierarchy were all "silent" about, even complicit in, the crimes of Nazism. But this astonishing book, published in 1941, at the height of Nazi tyranny, proves beyond doubt that the Church condemned Hitler and his ideology loudly, repeatedly, and from the very beginning of his rise to power.

Compiled by a highly-placed (and necessarily anonymous) German Catholic and translated into English, the book documents through 575 pages the Nazi government's persecution of the Catholic Church in Germany, and the response from Church officials:

"Here are the writings and speeches of the Pope and the German Hierarchy, the official decrees and instructions of the Government, and the speeches and teachings of the [Nazi] Party. The cumulative weight of this testimony is sufficient to establish the German persecution as the worst, because it is the most efficient, of modern times." -- The Commonweal (1941)

"Complete and devastating ... The facts are authentic and incontrovertible. The documents are likewise authentic and thoroughly substantiated. ... To anyone who thinks there is no persecution of the Catholic Church in Germany, we recommend this volume." -- America (1941)
14 posted on 07/23/2002 11:22:31 PM PDT by Pyro7480
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: Salvation
Ping post #14 and the entire thread.
15 posted on 07/23/2002 11:23:53 PM PDT by Pyro7480
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: Pyro7480; Salvation; Askel5; Romulus; Diago
Ditto. Ping. Bump
16 posted on 07/23/2002 11:35:21 PM PDT by Siobhan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies]

To: berned
Why is your anglefire link believable but not this article?
17 posted on 07/24/2002 2:47:27 AM PDT by patj
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Valin
The entire historical record indicates that Pius XII was the greatest friend the Jews of Europe had, throughout the years of the Nazi madness. There is nothing, not one scrap of documentary evidence, to indicate that Pius ever did or said anything in favor of the Nazi regime or against the Jewish people -- and the Pius-haters consistenly fail to confront the mountainous records about Pius's very high-risk labors to protect and preserve Jewish lives.

As the head of the Catholic Church and the potentate of a tiny country surrounded by a Nazi ally, Pius would have had very good reasons for doing nothing and saying nothing to help the Jews in their extremity. But he put himself, the Vatican, and the whole of European Catholicism on the line for God's Chosen People, the lineage from which Christ Himself sprang. And millions of American Catholics went to war against the Nazis because Pius told them, through their pastors, that it was their duty as men of decency and honor.

If there was ever a saint among men, a giant of compassion and courage under the most extraordinary conditions of hazard, it was Eugenio Pacelli, Pope Pius XII. He is one of the biggest reasons I am a Catholic, and proud to be one. They who attempt to besmirch his legacy are villains without a scrap of decency to their names.

Freedom, Wealth, and Peace,
Francis W. Porretto
Visit The Palace Of Reason:

18 posted on 07/24/2002 6:48:40 AM PDT by fporretto
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: patj
Unfortunately there are those who are ever ready to assume the worst when it comes to the Roman Catholic church and anyone connected to it. Fortunately for all reasonable people they get their theology from Chick comics.
As I've said before, it's amazing that the Christian Church is still around, after we've spent the last 2,000 years doing darn near everyting in our power to destroy it.
It almost makes a person think that we're NOT the ones in charge.
19 posted on 07/24/2002 10:23:07 AM PDT by Valin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: Valin; berned
berned is among the better-known disruptors on this forum, especially to Catholic threads. He's been shown to be dishonest and misleading by patent and Campion, among others, but he continues to trot out the same old tired stuff, hoping to catch someone new to his swill unawares.
20 posted on 07/24/2002 10:34:58 AM PDT by sinkspur
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]

Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-33 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson