I just thought that needed to be repeated.
Those who wish to criticize Islam, even if in very blunt or controversial fashion, should be free to speak within applicable FR guidelins. Indeed, legitimizing the concept of freedom of thought and speech regarding religion is a key part of our struggle against the absolutists of radical Islam. It must also, however painfully in some cases, be made clear to much of moderate Islam that they must also conform themselves in the West to this principle.
We can, however, legitimately propose and advocate that such religiously or broadly philosophical controversialism regarding Islam be relegated to the Religion section of FreeRepublic and/or The Smokey Backroom.