[berned]

Where have I lied?

Did you not post these words, Polycarp?

Bottom line: If the ossuary of James bar-Joseph is that of James the brother of the Lord, it sheds light on which of the theories Catholics are permitted to hold is most likely the correct one, but it poses does nothing to refute Catholic doctrine. If authentic, as seems probable, it is to be welcomed as further archaeological confirmation of the life of our Lord

Did you not write those words, Polycarp?

[berned]

You have called me a liar. I ask you, in the name of Jesus Christ, to answer me... Did YOU, or did you not -- write the words:

"If authentic, as seems probable, it is to be welcomed as further archaeological confirmation of the life of our Lord"

in the note which I referenced?