[sarcasm]

The four had lived together in an apartment on Senator Street in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, he said.

[Clemenza]

The four had lived together in an apartment on Senator Street in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, he said.

Despite being on the northernmost fringe of the neighborhood, Senator Street is still a decent part of Bay Ridge, comprised largely of single family homes. I have a feeling this guy lived in the building near 5th Avenue and Leif Ericson Park.