Did I ask about the "opinion"? I asked about YOUR opinion on the 9th Circuits Ruling upholding the California Assault Weapons Ban.
Myself, most of the other posters on this thread, four judges from an 11 judges panel on the 9th Circuit, severla judges on the 5th Circuit, several of the Founding Fathers, and most of history say that the ban is UnConstitutional for all the reasons mentioned.
What is YOUR opinion on the Ruling?
False naturally. Keep on begging the existence of that case or authority you've never been able to find.
Useful idiots presented the Ninth Circuit with a meritless case, and the Ninth gladly used the opportunity to fill its ruling with legal and historical falsehoods regarding the nature of the 2nd Amendment, knowing that its dicta was unnecessary to resolve the case and had no bearing on the judgment.