The Second Amendment and the Preamble to the Bill of Rights

The Sierra Times ^ | 11 June 2003 | Robert Greenslade and Claude Ellsworth

[tpaine]

To: Roscoe

Oh, and I think your actual line is identical to mine, I don't know why you're saying that I was wrong. Obviously the bracketed words are not intended to be ascribed to Rawle.
20 -AF-


Roscoe is a closet gun control FReak..
-- He likes to cloak his socialistic agenda with 'states rights' BS; --
-- but his true stripe shows up in his total support of the CA 'assault weapon' prohibitions..

He's a 'regulator'.
-- In his eyes, any level of government can stop any action or ban any article, if a 'socially good' reason to do so can be dreamed up by a moral majority.. - Its the democratic way, dontcha know..

[Roscoe]

support of the CA 'assault weapon' prohibitions..

False, sourceless. Naturally.

[Aric2000]

bttt

[Fiddlstix]

[tpaine]

The 'source' is your own posts.

Anyone can look up your comments on gun threads.
--You've been advocating the big government 'regulating' position here for years..

[Roscoe]

The 'source' is your own posts.

False.

[tpaine]

Denial

[tpaine]

COPS CRASH E HARLEM WEAPONS DEN (GUN CONFISCATION OF LAW ABIDING CITIZEN Thru Tip From Criminal)
http://www.FreeRepublic.com/focus/news/669831/posts

-- #1043 Roscoe on RTKBA

[Roscoe]

"This thread has been pulled."

[tpaine]

Hmmmm, -- why was that?


In any case, why don't you reiterate your real thoughts on the matter?
I believe they echoed many of Sara Brady's, but feel free to correct me.

[Roscoe]

why don't you reiterate your real thoughts on the matter?

OK. The protection of the right to keep and bear arms at the state level has always had its foundations in state constitutions and state laws.

You're free to try to produce so much as a single exception.

You can't, you won't. Old news.

[tpaine]

The protection of the right to keep and bear arms {at the state level} has always had its foundations in state constitutions and state laws.

You're free to try to produce so much as a single exception.
You can't, you won't. Old news.
31 -roscoe-


What an absolutely daffy statement. Why would ~anyone~ try to find an "exception" to such an obviously redundant bit of idiocy?

However, the position that:

--- 'The protection of the right to keep and bear arms has always had its foundations in state constitutions and state laws' --,
-- certainly can be held; --

-- ignoring the fact that it has little or no bearing on your being a closet gun grabber, roscoe..

[Roscoe]

Why would ~anyone~ try to find an "exception

Because that person had taken the inane contrary position that centralized federal power and an activist federal judiciary should replace those state mechanisms.

Poor you.

[tpaine]

Even more daffy that you would imagine an opponent of yours has taken such an inane contrary position, roscoe.

Poor you, -- you seem to be grabbing at straws.

[Mulder]

But they are all safe books which have been appoved for general reading by government-trained educators.

Good analogy.

[Travis McGee]

Thanks for coming around to bump the thread. Your support is appreciated.

[Travis McGee]

Thanks, I wish I could claim I had thought up the book analogy.

[Roscoe]

Strange comment, coming from an apologist for Roe v Wade.

[tpaine]

Roscoe is a closet gun control FReak..
-- He likes to cloak his socialistic agenda with 'states rights' BS; --
-- but his true stripe shows up in his total support of the CA 'assault weapon' prohibitions..
He's a 'regulator'.
-- In his eyes, any level of government can stop any action or ban any article, if a 'socially good' reason to do so can be dreamed up by a moral majority.. - Its the democratic way, dontcha know..
-21-



As I said above, roscoe, you're a 'regulator'.. You want big brother to prohibit guns, outlaw drugs, ban abortion, and no doubt, banish all known 'sin' by taxing it to death. -- Blue nosed socialism like yours is a disease. Get medical help.

[Roscoe]

Sourceless falsehoods are all you have.