Posted on 07/26/2003 4:11:29 PM PDT by Dr. Marten
We made it
Walter Williams (archive)
Whenever someone says that this or that government program is absolutely necessary, I always wonder, "What did people do and how did they survive before the program?"
If someone says food stamps are absolutely necessary for poor people's survival, I wonder how America's millions of poor immigrants made it. Unless I missed something, mass starvation is not a part of our history. Was there a stealth food stamp program during the 1700s and 1800s?
Then there's the question: How did we manage to build the world's greatest cities without the help of the 1965-created U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development? Did cities become worse off or better off afterward? Or, how did we manage to produce energy to fuel the world's richest economy before the 1977 creation of the Department of Energy?
Recently, I received an email titled, "We Made It." It had to do with the federal safety edicts of agencies like the U.S. Product Safety Commission, established in 1972, and the U.S. Department of Transportation, established in 1966. Congress created these and other agencies to "protect the public against unreasonable risks of injuries and deaths." That's how toys, cribs, child car seats and childproof medicine bottles came to be regulated. Considering we were a nation for nearly 200 years before Congress started protecting us against "unreasonable risks of injuries and deaths," a natural question is how we managed to survive and grow from a population of 4 million to the 280 million of us today.
According to my email's author, if we listen to Washington, those of us still around who were children during the '40s, '50s and '60s probably should be dead. Nonetheless, there are 58 million of us born in 1945 or earlier who are still kicking. Our parents allowed us to sleep in cribs beautified with lead-based paint. They drove us around in cars that had neither seatbelts nor airbags. They permitted us to ride our bicycles without helmets, just as adults rode motorcycles without helmets. And, horror of horrors, there were no childproof medicine bottles that, by the way, are sometimes so difficult to open that some people summon their children to open them.
The fact that these safety edicts saved some lives and prevented some injuries doesn't provide justification for them anymore than mandating that, because some Americans have headaches, aspirin be put in the water supply.
In a free society, government has the responsibility of protecting us from others, but not from ourselves. Before government got into the business of protecting us from ourselves, we did have a greater measure of protection from others. Yesteryear's children rode their bikes or walked to a friend's house, knocked on the door and let themselves in. Many families didn't lock doors until the last family member was home for the evening, and they did that in poor neighborhoods like the one I grew up in.
Yesteryear, when we went off to school, parents might have worried about our crossing streets safely. Today's parents have a different set of worries, such as whether their child will be shot, stabbed, robbed, raped or given drugs in school. During the pre-1960 years, neighborhoods -- including poor neighborhoods -- were safe enough for women to walk the streets after dark. In fact, in places like Harlem, N.Y., hot, humid nights saw children and adults sleeping on fire escapes and rooftops. Doing the same today might lead to arrest for attempted suicide.
Speaking of crime, if children did have a scrape with the law, our parents sided with the police.
Don't you wonder how so many Americans made it without today's oppressive, caring, nanny government?
You got it right; and may get harder. There is a large and growing voter bloc of people who don't want to "make it" on there own and they are voting with your pocketbook. These include the parasites, the lazy, the illegals (who can't make it on their own even if they want to), the addicted, those who demand special treatment/status, etc..... They will have a big influence on who gets electfied.
No kidding. I saw that for myself in one former neighborhood of mine. A few of the kids were real troublemakers. When the cops would come rolling in, these punks' disconnected mothers would come running out of the house to meet them, defending their little creeps. Right is wrong, up is down, black is white.
Or even let us steer(legs too short to reach the pedals) sitting on their laps on the back roads(and that was the early '70's in NJ!).
The fact that these safety edicts saved some lives and prevented some injuries doesn't provide justification for them anymore than mandating that, because some Americans have headaches, aspirin be put in the water supply.
Another killer Dr. Williams line!
Oh yeah! I've thought about writting in his name for President(I know he would never subject himself to that(prove me wrong Dr. Williams!) with Dr. Sowell for VP ;-)
If someone says food stamps are absolutely necessary for poor people's survival, I wonder how America's millions of poor immigrants made it. Unless I missed something, mass starvation is not a part of our history. Was there a stealth food stamp program during the 1700s and 1800s?
Then there's the question: How did we manage to build the world's greatest cities without the help of the 1965-created U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development? Did cities become worse off or better off afterward? Or, how did we manage to produce energy to fuel the world's richest economy before the 1977 creation of the Department of Energy?
And how the hell did hollywood and Broadway come into being without the National Endowments of the Arts? How did ANY painter, or playwright ever exist without it?
And how the hell did we teach our kids, build our schools, without the Department of Education?
And DON'T tell me that seniors took care of their own retirement plans, before Social Security ever came into being. Nope. Never happened.
Common sense is something liberals lack. In their view there is no problem that a government program can't fix even if the problem was caused by a government program.
How Did We Ever Survive? We drew war pictures in grade school and played Cowboys and Indians, yet were the active generation protesting Vietnam. We bore the undiluted brunt of nuclear war scenarios with only the palliative of 'duck and cover' for our fears. There were no 'grief counselors' at our schools as polio raced through the nation. The medium of our destruction was comic books not videogames, the only one of which was 'Winky Dink and You.'
We made it in spite of iron lungs, mumps, unchecked air pollution, muscle cars, swamp coolers, faith healers, dry counties, and orphanages. "I'm still here, you bastards!"
|
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.