Are you PCA now?
When we first moved here, we did attend a PCA Church for awhile - great people but I have to admit that I did not like the minister at all...... strange man and I got an almost cultish feeling from him - but I absolutely am NOT saying that goes for any other PCA congregation - it is just the one that is closest to us.
We have been attending a non-denominational Church lately - I've really enjoyed the sermons - very thought provoking -