...inventing a new concept.
No. Describing a reality. Do you believe the Pope is irresistable? Yes or No? If yes, Why?
yet again to explain your schism from the Pope.
No. It doesn't explain a schism that never happened. That is irrelevant anyway as to whether or not the Pope is irresistible or not. The term "irresistibility" describes the errors of those who believe the Pope is irresistible. This is of course un-Catholic.
Lefebvre was hell-bent to keep his little movement going. He would defy the Pope, regardless.
As long as the Pope acts like Peter at Antioch and worse, he is fully justified in passing on the faith undiluted with the errors of JPII.
Welcome to the witches brew that is the FR religion forum.
Thank you.
You traddies are like termites, coming out of the woodwork. Did Vennari send you over here?
Very charitable of you. But I'm used to over-emotionalism from Neo-Catholics. As Gerry Matatics told me, "as long as you don't crumble when someone calls you names, you can keep speaking the truth." No. Mr. Vennari didn't send me over. Patrick Madrid basically did. You can thank him. After I mopped up the floor with him and the others who took shots at "traddies" and when he was backed into a corner and made to look foolish by his positions, (Basically, I just asked him how many people he actually interviewed who currently attend Masses by the SSPX, and how many times and chapels he'd actually visited ) he did the only thing left to him and deleted all of the posts and deleted my registration. I'm currently disembowling his latest screed. "More Catholic Than the Pope" in fulfillment of a promise I made to him. My red pen is running out of ink, it is so full of errors.
Uh-huh. Sure. Any fool can come on a website and say anything.
I've read Patrick's book, and it's quite good, though I wish he had spread his focus to the independents and sedevacantists.
He makes his points well, however. And, his bona fides are well-established.
I'll believe you backed him into a corner when hell freezes over.
Until then, have fun with your "irresistibilities". No doubt you'll be writing a book for The Remnant, Traditio, or any of a number of sectarian sites, trashing Madrid a-la Woods and Ferrara.
Does Gerry Matatics applaud your following a dead archbishop? I doubt it, since Matatics is thoroughly Catholic, and will not renounce John Paul II.
for tomorrow