[WriteOn]

Clearly you're not appealing to the tradition of the Latin rite, but to rite-changers or other faiths?

Is this a point of dissent with the magisterium for you?

[sinkspur]

Clearly you're not appealing to the tradition of the Latin rite, but to rite-changers or other faiths?

Is this a point of dissent with the magisterium for you?

Celibacy is a discipline of the Latin Rite. It is not a dogma, or even a teaching. So, there is no "dissent with the magisterium" involved here.