Marcel and his episcopal rebels were excommunicated. They fail the Catholic test. Case closed unless and until JP II says otherwise. He is pope. You are not and neither was the nefarious Marcel.
Sure. Since you order me to go do my own research, I'll tell you where to stick it. The only difference is I can do it with facts and not lies. You were the one that set the tone. Now it's going to bite you in the rear. Got it?
These arguments between Church and schismatics have been going on here for years before you arrived and they are going to be going on long after you will probably be gone.
Sing songs little boy. I've dealt with much better than you. At least they weren't boring with their repetitive dronings.
Wallow in your schism, risk the consequences, all in the exercise of the free will that God gave you.
Blah blah blah. Even if you were right in some bizaaro world. The filth you peddle and your lack of charity would turn anyone off from the Catholic Church. Thank God you are an apostate. Maybe when you clean up and see the light, you'll behave more amicably.
If you are going to dress up and play Catholic on the Internet, those who ARE Catholic are going to respond in defense of the Church.
Right!!!! You'd have to know the Catholic faith to "dress up like it" unfortunately your intellect is so darkened you can't even recognize it. Don't even pretend that a rank and I mean RANK amatuer like yourself has the stuff to do it.
Say what you please. So will we.
I'll say 2+2=4 and you'll say anything else. One of us is right. Me. Deal with it.
The schism has never earned the right to be engaged in the realm of principles or ideas.
You have YET to discuss an idea. Your just a parrot of Apostasy. Want a cracker?
The Church has no obligation to assist you in your attempts to appear to have earned that right. Rome is the standard. Your sorry CULT is the deviation.
You don't even know what the Catholic Church is much less it's mission. I hope to God you were baptized as a baby because then you have hope.
Do you deny that MARCEL AND EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOUR BISHOPS are excommunicated?
Yes. They are invalidly declared self excommunicated "on the books" by Cardinal Gantin and JPII foolishly agreed with it. Gantin was wrong, JPII was wrong. There was no papal excommunication.
Do you deny that the SSPX is a schism?
Yes. Since no schismatic act occurred the Pope committed a great crime with his cowardly capitulation to the modernists and God will punish him for that. Do you know what a schism is? What it means? hint: Think Orthodox.
JP II is pope. Test passed.
Bull. You know nothing of the papacy. Do you think the Pope is irresistible and impeccable? If so, please cite...oh nevermind. you won't.
The Holy Ghost provides no heretics as pope.
Guess again amateur John XXII held heretical views and didn't recant till shortly before his death. And Vatican I found 40 instances of error in papal (non-universal) teaching.
Marcel and his episcopal rebels were excommunicated.
Nope. Unless excommunicated has a new meaning. Like "remaining Catholic" This lie about excommunication has very short legs. It didn't go very far and no one not even JPII uses the term after 1988. Because deep down, HE KNOWS.
They fail the Catholic test. Case closed unless and until JP II says otherwise. He is pope. You are not and neither was the nefarious Marcel.
Here's a bit of advice. Learn something about the papacy and then come back and try again. Till then, you're just an unCatholic broken record spouting out misinformation about Christ's promises.