Perhaps, but utilitarianism is a slippery slope. Conservatives are supposed to be about principles. Conservatives are the ones who should be asking why the State, not in cases of emergency, but in the normal course of business, should have the right to compel service from its (wink, wink) "citizens".
"Perhaps, but utilitarianism is a slippery slope."
I'm not a utilitarian.
"Conservatives are supposed to be about principles."
One of mine is that Americans owe something to America.
"Conservatives are the ones who should be asking why"
No, conservatives already know the answer. Pretending there isn't one is the province of (wink, wink) libertarians.