Posted on 11/28/2005 10:26:32 AM PST by Dumb_Ox
In 1968 Howard B. White published Peace among the Willows, the first book-length analysis of Bacons New Atlantis. White, a political theorist who regards Bacon as a principal shaper of modern political ideas, maintains that it is this utopian work and not one of Bacons philosophical treatises that provides the fullest statement of Bacons political theory. White is especially interested in what he regards as Bacons secularization of politics and glorification of the power of science to serve the interests of the secular state. In developing his argument, White maintains that New Atlantis must be read with meticulous care in order to understand Bacons complex interweaving and transformation of political iconography, ancient history and fables, religious symbols, scientific methodologies, and pseudo-scientific concepts. White devotes considerable attention to Bacons use of religious themes and argues that he manipulates them in order to subvert Christian ideas and transform them into a culturally acceptable justification for a preoccupation with luxury and materialism. According to White, Bacons purpose is to transform the human quest from the search for the heavenly city to the creation of the well-governed country, and to change the philosophical quest from an effort to understand God, Gods Creation, and humanitys place in it to a pursuit to understand what humans can make of themselves.Whites work has been highly influential and augmented more recently by another political philosopher, Jerry Weinberger. Weinberger also argues that Bacons utopia provides a primary source for understanding the transitional phase from early modern political ideas to those of the modern age, and he maintains that Bacon manipulates religious language and concepts to conceal his secular agenda. Recently, considerable attention to Bacons New Atlantis has also come from the new historical criticism. Studies by Charles Whitney, Amy Boesky, and others have analyzed utopian literature as a primary source for understanding the founding fictions and political ideologies underpinning nationalism, imperialism, colonialism, and overseas expansion. Like White and Weinberger, many cultural historians treat Bacons manipulation of religious ideas as a way of providing cultural authority for his political agenda. Marina Leslie, for example, asserts that Bacon inverts the spiritual and material worlds, and claims that Bacon transforms spiritual salvation into material well-being accomplished by humans and not by God. David Innes, a theologian influenced by White, contends that Bacon is responsible for transmuting Christian hope for spiritual salvation into a secular dream of material comfort and argues that the Christianity of Bensalem is actually a fundamental assault upon, transformation of and ultimate displacement of Christianity. Denise Albanese asserts that Bensalemite Christianity first serves as yet another instance of reverse colonialism, with the natives conversion already an accomplished fact and as the code for an intellectual imperialism.
This essay contends that it is a misunderstanding and distortion to view Bacons use of religious language and concepts as disingenuous and manipulative. It demonstrates that Bacons program of utopian reform, as presented in New Atlantis, is grounded in genuinely and deeply felt religious convictions, which serve as the foundation for his program of political and social prosperity through the advancement of learning.
Interesting. Marking for later read.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.