To a certain extent, notes Jay Ambrose, the Anglican controversy was caused as much by the Episcopal Church's arrogance as its apostasy:
More Episcopal parishes voted over the weekend to leave the U.S. church, and perhaps those responsible for the parishioners’ anguish over the direction of this Christian denomination feel little remorse. Perhaps they think they stood tall for the moral good when they decided as they did in national conventions on the question of homosexuality.
But theirs was, in my view, a narrow, proud and pointlessly provocative act when they accepted an openly gay man as bishop of the Diocese of New Hampshire and agreed that parishes could bless same-sex unions if they chose.
Nothing was more important to TEC than Gene Robinson's pointy hat. Not even African lives.
They could have found other ways less offensive to many fellow Episcopalians to address wrongs done to gays and lesbians while also understanding that their shrug of the shoulders about scripture could have serious, adverse consequences for Anglican brothers and sisters struggling for their very lives in Africa.
TEC's relentless invocation of the word "homophobia" is a lie and TEC knows it.
It is not the case, after all, that prior to these decisions America’s Episcopalians were denying homosexuals loving acceptance in their churches. Even those feeling that homosexual conduct was irrefutably sinful would scarcely need reminding what the Christian faith holds - that we are all sinners, everyone of us.
GenCon delegates could have found more constructive and less provocative ways to deal with the issues at hand.
With little fear of contradiction, convention delegates could have said we need to pay special attention to the bigotry that so often afflicts homosexuals and think through what sorts of social and political positions might most effectively curtail it. They could also have begun a discussion of whether there were sound theological grounds to ignore Paul’s injunction in the New Testament to abjure homosexual behavior.
But rather than do any of that, the Episcopal Church deliberately flipped off the entire Anglican world.
Instead, a majority of the delegates seemed to believe that nothing less would do than to allow Gene Robinson of New Hampshire to ascend to the role of bishop, male companion in tow. The scriptural issue? Some delegates said they were guided by the Holy Spirit, which can be an excuse for almost anything unless you look to fellow believers to confirm that they, too, are so moved. In the case of the worldwide Anglican communion - some 70 million people, of which 2.3 million are Episcopalians - there was no such confirmation.
Twice.
In fact, some were outraged - especially Africans - and the archbishop of Canterbury did his best within limited powers to avoid a rift in the world communion, asking that Episcopalians find a way to soften what they had done. In their most recent national meeting, they elected as the U.S. presiding bishop a woman who had favored Robinson’s being named as a bishop and gave a sermon referring to "Mother Jesus," a peculiar way of healing wounds with traditionalists.
Spurious issues like episcopal boundary crossing, the increasingly regular use of words like bigotry, hatred and fascism and strident assertions that orthodox Anglicans are doing violence to the "Anglican tradition" should not obscure the fact that the controversy in the Anglican world is entirely the fault of the Episcopal Church.
And if TEC is run from the Anglican world, it may howl, it will probably sue American Anglican parishes and dioceses that wish to seperate from it or it may say, "Good riddance," run up the United Nations flag and start its own crypto-Unitarian "Anglican Communion" with whatever provinces want to join it. But whatever happens, the fault will be entirely its own.
Traditional Anglican ping, continued in memory of its founder Arlin Adams. Looking back at the events since Robinson was consecrated, where on these threads some first openly used the word schism, I am surprised, amazed even, at how far an dhow fast events have progressed. I think TEC had no idea that this would happen.they figured they could talk us to death again. I mean, look at Kate's consecration present, one whole diocese in California ups and leaves, and 20% or so, and the most viable part of the diocese of Va also heads for the safety of the hills. I think TEC establishment has NO clue as to what is going on...