Oh I think you do. You started them.
Really?? Please point out precisely where in any of my postings on this thread I did any such.
You made the statement "Gnosticism started way before Christianity and the Apostle Paul was up to his ears in it." And I asked for a clarification of what you were referring to, as you replied to post #20, which was actually Beachdwellers (not mine)--but you included me in your reply for some unknown reason.
So, I'll say it again---if you think you have something true to add to the discussion, post it. Otherwise shut up.