Posted on 02/01/2009 9:28:33 PM PST by Between the Lines
Despite his role in President Obama’s inauguration and the attention he received in the weeks leading into it, megachurch pastor Rick Warren is known to only about half of Americans, according to a recent survey.
World renowned evangelist Billy Graham, meanwhile, remains the most well known among the nation’s high profile televangelists and megachurch leaders, with 88 percent claiming that they were familiar with him, according to HCD Research.
The results of the survey, conducted Jan. 27-28, were released a little more than a week after Warren, senior pastor of Saddleback Church in Lake Forrest, Calif., delivered the invocation at the presidential inauguration on Jan. 20, and weeks after Obama’s tapping of Warren spurred highly-publicized protests from the gay community.
Despite all the media attention, only 49 percent of Americans surveyed by HCD said they were familiar with Warren, placing him between controversial preachers Jeremiah Wright (56 percent) and Benny Hinn (48 percent). Notably, however, the latest statistic is a big improvement from the 28 percent of Americans who said they had heard of Warren in 2006, when the faith-based Barna Group surveyed American adults regarding the nation's leading Christian ministers.
For the latest survey, HCD presented 803 participants with a list of 32 televangelists and megachurch leaders and asked them to rate each figure based on six attributes, including familiarity, likeability, believability, authenticity/sincerity, personal impact and level of controversy.
The list extended somewhat beyond televangelists and megachurch leaders as it included Graham, an ordained Baptist minister and on-stage evangelist, as well as United Methodist minister Joseph Lowery, the civil rights leader who delivered the benediction at Obama’s inauguration last month.
Others on the list included charismatic moguls Pat Robertson and Oral Roberts, prosperity preachers Joel Osteen and T.D. Jakes, and megachurch pastors Bill Hybels and Craig Groeschel.
According to the results of HCD’s survey, rated highest in level of controversy was Jeremiah Wright, the former pastor of the Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago who placed former church member Obama in hot water after past sermons were splashed across the internet, including one in which he said “God damn America.”
Rated lowest in authenticity/sincerity, meanwhile, was Ted Haggard, the former pastor of the New Life Church in Colorado Springs, Colo., who was ousted by the church he founded over a highly publicized drug and sex scandal.
Coincidentally, or perhaps intentionally, the results of HCD’s survey were released on the same day that HBO was scheduled to air "The Trials of Ted Haggard," a 41-minute documentary that paints a sympathetic portrait of Haggard after the scandal in 2006 brought down the charismatic leader and forced him out of Colorado.
Since Jan. 9, Haggard has given dozens of media interviews after years out of the public eye and appeared on "Larry King Live" this past Thursday.
|
Total (n=803) |
Billy Graham |
88% |
Pat Robertson |
80% |
Jimmy Swaggart |
73% |
Oral Roberts |
69% |
Joel Osteen |
67% |
Jeremiah Wright |
56% |
Rick Warren |
49% |
Benny Hinn |
48% |
T.D. Jakes |
40% |
Robert A. Schuller |
38% |
Ted Haggard |
36% |
Robert Tilton |
29% |
Creflo Dollar |
25% |
Rod Parsley |
23% |
Joseph Lowery |
23% |
Eddie Long |
13% |
Frederick Eikerenkoetter ("Rev Ike") |
13% |
Charles Blake |
11% |
H. Edwin Young |
10% |
Bill Hybels |
10% |
Andy Stanley |
8% |
William Sheals |
8% |
Chuck Smith |
8% |
Tommy J. Barnett |
8% |
Zachery Tims |
7% |
Craig Groeschel |
6% |
Billy James Hargis |
6% |
Bob Russell |
6% |
Kerry Shook |
5% |
Brad Powell |
5% |
Dave Stone |
5% |
Bob Coy |
4% |
http://hcdi.net/News/MediacurvesRelease.cfm?M=254
If I understand correctly, Billy Graham gradually came under considerable criticism over the decades as there did not seem to be a single president whom “the pastor to the presidents” ever saw fit to publicly criticize or break with.
Rick Warren seems to be outdoing Graham in that regard.
Well at least Warren edges out Benny Hinn and Ted Haggart.
Graham made his agenda clear, preaching the Cross and Salvation, he did it year after year, decade after decade.
I doubt it.
looks like a seriously BS list, which probably ommitted many better known pastors.
The glaring omissions (Where is Charles Colson, of prison fellowship ministries? Angel tree ring a bell?) make this highly suspect survey suitable only for the round file.
I don’t know who a few of those are but of the ones I do know I wouldn’t give a wooden nickle for. Here are the ones I don’t know.
Creflo Dollar
Eddie Long
Frederick Eikerenkoetter
Charles Blake
H. Edwin Young
Andy Stanley (Is he related to Charles Stanley?)
William Sheals
Chuck Smith
Tommy J. Barnett
Zachery Tims
Craig Groeschel
Billy James Hargis
Bob Russell
Kerry Shook
Brad Powell
Dave Stone
Bob Coy
Here are some the (living) preachers I like in no particular order.
Paul Chapel
R.B. Oulette
Sam Davison
Troy Dorrell
Dave Hardy
Wayne Hardy
Dean Herring
David Gibbs
Kenny Baldwin
Clifton Mizer
Greg Locke
There are many more if anyone cares.
Well at least Warren edges out Benny Hinn and Ted Haggart.
Neck and neck with Tofik Benedictus Hinn.
I am not familiar with many of the names on the list. And though Tims, Smith and Stanley all fall below the 8% mark on this list, they scored highest in good atributes
Attribute |
Highest Rated |
Lowest Rated |
Familiarity |
Billy Graham |
William Sheals |
Likeability |
Zachery Tims |
Jeremiah Wright |
Believability |
Zachery Tims |
Jeremiah Wright |
Authenticity/Sincerity |
Zachery Tims |
Ted Haggard |
Personal Impact |
Joel Olsteen |
Ted Haggard |
Level of Controversy |
Jeremiah Wright |
Robert A.Schuller |
No methodology is mentioned at the website, but I would guess this lists originated with the pollsters and not those being polled.
John Hagee, my favorite and far above Warren, didn’t make the list?
I actually laughed the first time I read this. Judging from recent headlines those who have first learned of Warren recently vehemently disapprove of him. The author's "big improvement" comment seems to confuse fame with popularity.
Similarly Jeremiah Wright would probably not have made this list in 2006. Now he is very well know and quite possibly the most hated pastor in America.
John Hagee, my favorite
Smile when you say that. Hagee has "issues".
Lee,
Everybody has issues. I like most of his messages and he is not afraid to take a stand.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.