My guess was “The Quiet Man.”
Regarding “It’s a Wonderful Life,” I really don’t like James Stewart that much, as an actor. Not that he isn’t good, objectively, but he just doesn’t appeal to me. And I’m annoyed by the mispresentation of angels, who are, from Creation, “created spirits without bodies,” and none of this confusion about their being somehow transformed from people.
And also, the Baileys should have more children. Everyone has just two children in the movies, unless it’s one of those big-family shows, when in context, everyone would have been saying, “What’s wrong? Is she sick? Don’t they *like* each other?” if people had only two children.
They had four: Pete, Tommy, Janie and Zuzu.