[NYer]

You just lost credibility. Someone can read a hundred books and hear a million stories, but if they haven’t been married and personally raised the children that are the fruits of a marriage, then they are the farthest thing from an expert.

Would you apply the same thought process towards your wife's selection of an Ob/Gyn? Or what about a female Ob/Gyn who never gave birth? How well equipped are either of these physicians, to deliver babies?

[Flightdeck]

“Would you apply the same thought process towards your wife’s selection of an Ob/Gyn? Or what about a female Ob/Gyn who never gave birth? How well equipped are either of these physicians, to deliver babies?”

Of course I would. I would much prefer an Ob/Gyn who had experience delivering babies instead of one who had never done so before. In fact, that is a very good example that supports my argument. Was that a trick question? Or did you not apply your own analogy appropriately?