Replies

“My personal belief is that God brought to Mary’s womb the already formed embryo-aged Jesus for implantation.”
This is an echo of Henry Morris's attempt to solve a non-existent problem. In one of the Institute for Creation Research bulletins from the late 1970s, Morris reasoned himself into a corner by saying that since Jesus had to be the perfect lamb of God and since lambs for Passover in which there was any defect were rejected and since sin had had a corrupting effect on the human race and since Mary was part of the human race, then Jesus could not be the perfect lamb of God and have come from the sin-corrupted flesh of Mary and, so, must have been created ex nihilo within Mary's womb.

Aside from the problem of a divine in utero creation not being a conception, as was stated in the accounts, Morris fundamentally misunderstands the nature of sin as well as the nature of nature. According to Paul, the reason creation is subject to decay is not because it has been "invaded and corrupted" by sin, but because God subjected it temporarily to this "frustration" and "bondage of decay" until such time that "the creation itself will be liberated from its bondage to decay and brought into the freedom and glory of the children of God" (Romans 8). Sin matters but sin is not matter. Matter is not evil. Matter is not sinful. Matter does not transmit sin. Sin is not inherited through DNA, genomic or mitochondrial. Morris, and others who come up with similar schemes, are trying to solve a problem that doesn't exist.

Very elegant argument.

And it is because I agree that matter is not evil that I do not believe Mary needed to be born sinless. It is because I do not believe Adam's sin is transmitted via a gene pool that I do not believe Mary needed to be born sinless.

Humankind are unique in the animal world due to their soul having a spirit. It is because their spirits were alive that they could comprehend good and evil, but in learning of it the way they did, they rebeled against God's authority and the Life in their spirits left and in that day they died. This lead to their being cut off from the fruit of the Tree of Life which caused their physical life to begin decaying, but they did not die physically for quite sometime after their fall from Grace.

When God created Adam and breathed into him a living soul, Adam had an alive spirit animating his soul. When the first couple sinned, they lost that characteristic of 'alive souls' via God breathed life in their spirit, so they passed to all their descendants a spirit without God-life in it, thus all descendants of Adam have a lifeless spirit ... where Life is defined as God-life in the spirit. That Life can be restored because of The Grace of God in Christ Jesus.

Jesus taught us about this state of existence with the scene of the rich young ruler who pleaded that he had to go bury his father before he could follow Jesus (let the dead go bury the dead). But that is yet another issue over which our Catholic brethren will likley berate me, so I'll bow out of this thread at this point.