1. Wise government may tolerate error for the sake of peace, but error has no rights. I believe I have shown this to be traditional Church teaching.
2. I would certainly fear Hell if I fell into heresy, schism, or apostasy.
3. No. Where did you get that idea?
Then you concede three. Ok.
1, We’re not in the Papal states, anymore.
2, Are you required to be a member of the Catholic church to be saved? Doesn’t seem to me to be the case.