If I may ask one basic question here: What is the purpose for speaking in tongues today?
All the usages of tongues in Pauls treatment of the subject refer to foreign languages. So likewise ye, except ye utter by the tongue words easy to be understood, how shall it be known what is spoken? for ye shall speak into air (1 Corinthians 14:9).
There is no reason for anyone to speak except to converse intelligibly. The Greek word laleo means I speak. The word is never used for mere sound or noise. Nor is it used for a mere mumbling or muttering of unintelligible gibberish. The tongues-speaking in the New Testament was in the native languages of hearing people. The supernatural phenomenon which took place at Pentecost was the exercise of a gift whereby many people from many countries, gathered at Jerusalem, heard Gods message in their own language. This was indeed a miracle of God.
It would be an arbitrary and strange interpretation of Scripture that would make tongues-speaking in the New Testament anything other than known languages. There is no trace of Scriptural evidence that tongues were ever heard by anyone as incoherent, incomprehensible babbling.
http://bible.org/article/speaking-tongues
I keep hearing that it's THE evidence of the baptism of the Holy Spirit. That way I can know I've got it.
As if I wouldn't be able to tell that God did something so significant in my life without it.
But I'd be interested in what the tongues defenders have to say.