Catholic Conservatives can assume that it was a good thing that the registered Catholic voters that did not vote, did not vote, a reasonable guess is that they would have gone more than 54% for Obama, let the non-voters and non-absentee voters, stay home. The Democrats know what they are doing when they try to drag them to the voting booths.
Obama got 69.5 million votes, only 12 million of which were from Catholics. That means he got 57.5 million votes from non-Catholics representing a nearly 4:1 edge. Maybe you ought to look beyond your prejudices to see exactly who elected him.
Peace be with you.