Any religion that declares that the first eleven chapters of Genesis are literal but denies the virgin birth or the Real Presence in the Eucharist is indeed suspect.
Peace be with you
You do understand that there's not "new testament" in my Bible and that your invoking it is no different than invoking the "book of mormon" . . . correct?
If G-d was not truthful (chas vechalilah!) about the events of Genesis 1-11, why do you Catholics trust Him on other matters? Aren't you rejecting Genesis 1-11 for purely sociological reasons?