[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: Theological Virtues, Faith
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: The Spiritual Works of Mercy
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: The Corporal Works of Mercy
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: HOLY ORDERS
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: The Anointing of the Sick (formerly Extreme Unction)
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: Holy Matrimony
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: CONFIRMATION
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: The Blessed Eucharist
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: CONFESSION (Penance/Reconciliation)
[Catholic Caucus] Lenten Series 2015: BAPTISM
Think of something like Project Rachael. How awful would it be to hit a poor, aching, confused heart, knowing she had done something awful, with the kind of self-righteous, damned-to-hell spiel that would make her want to run away from the very help she sought! One must, at least for awhile separate the person and the act, and see the agony inside that needs healing first. When the woman threw herself at Jesus' feet and wept, he didn't kick her in the head. He gave her the chance to express her sorrow and love; he admonished the people who would have had her taken out; then He forgave her, with the admonishment to go and sin no more.
Conversely, a person in addiction may need a tough-love intervention. This has to be an accountability for what the person has done and how it has affected others, as well as the person themselves. Yet it must be done with Christian charity, remembering the focus is the addict's welfare. Looking down at others and taking pride in, even enjoying, the opportunity to chastise another in the name of being a Christian, is simply not Christian, and may be the person's ruin, not their salvation.
When seeking to show mercy, we need to pray for discernment as to what to do and how to do it. We need to pray for the grace to do good for the greater honor and glory of God and the good of souls: not for our own edification.