Believe it or not, I a sympathetic to many of the arguments that traddies make.
What always turns me off is the holier than thou attitude that many of them have.
JPII and Benedict were/are holy men, but they were not perfect as Popes. We may not fully understand how they decided to handle internal corruption, which it is now clear they were aware of.
I suspect you didn’t understand my post. When I say they were all cut from the same cloth, I mean they are/were all Modernists. In other words, they are all part of the Revolution that happened decades ago. The revolutionaries are just more in your face these days.