Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

To: Catholicguy
Narses specialises in posting stuff that undermines the authority of the Hierarchy or is critical of the Pope and this is just Commie garbage is yet ANOTHER example of how he tries to frighten others and undermine their confidence.

Your post is both dishonest (I post many things and what I try to do is elicit comments from which I can learn) and cowardly (as you don't "ping" me as I am told is the custom here). I have asked you before and I ask you again, stop attacking me.

120 posted on 07/27/2002 3:42:21 PM PDT by narses
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 116 | View Replies ]


To: narses
Narses specialises in posting stuff that undermines the authority of the Hierarchy or is critical of the Pope and this is just Commie garbage is yet ANOTHER example of how he tries to frighten others and undermine their confidence. (That was an excellent encapsulation. Thanks for reposting it). Your post is both dishonest (I post many things and what I try to do is elicit comments from which I can learn) and cowardly (as you don't "ping" me as I am told is the custom here). I have asked you before and I ask you again, stop attacking me

ALL my posts are honest and I have no hidden agenda. You became a member on 6/22/02. I think your first post came at 5:01. It was an attack on The Magisterium. You attacked the decision of the Roman Curia that speaks in the name of the Pope and you, intentionally or not, mischaracterised the decison of that Curial Office AND you, mistakenly of falsely, accused one of the Churches involved as being heretical. I have since corrected this error publicly at least three times. Sitetest has corected you on the same error. Patent has corrected you on the same error. I have no doubt you still hold your personal opinion to be the correct one and that you reject the decision of the Magisterium. Youhave eeven said the Mass was invalid AFTER the Curia had taken its decision speaking for the Divinely-constitued authority. You may fool some. You haven't fooled me for an instant.

You have been unrelenting since. I went back and checked. You have a pattern of supporting the sspx schism. I have noted that, so has patent and st chuck; others have also, as I recall. Your posts succoring the schism of the sspx are taken from public opponents of the Pope - The Remnant,Catholic Family News, Seattle Catholic etc. You may fool some folks. You do not fool me.

An OVERWHELMING percentage of your posts concerning the Pope or The Magisterium are attacks, some subtle, some bold. You have yet to post a piece defending the Pope in any controversial aspect of his Papacy. You always side with those who cast his actions in a negative light. You may fool some folks. You don't fool me. There ARE perfectly rational and defensible explanations for why the Pope does what he does. You have never posted them. When those explanations ARE posted, from the TCRnews website, you place yourself in opposition to those articles. You may fool some folks. You don't fool me.

133 posted on 07/28/2002 5:29:51 AM PDT by Catholicguy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 120 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson