Can dogs and cats really find their way home over long distances, as in "Incredible Journey"?

Are there any reliable accounts that dogs (and/or cats, which I doubt highly) have been able to find their way home over long distances a la The Incredible Journey and Old Yeller? If so, is there any explanation for this? Is this all a bunch of pet-lover hooey?--Mike Bauman

It's not all pet-lover hooey. A certain amount of New Age pseudoscientific hooey enters into it, too. Still, setting aside obvious instances of exaggeration, wishful thinking, etc., I have to agree that at least some animals have impressive navigational skills. As for explanations--well, some of those are definitely incredible.

Ask any collection of pet owners and you're sure to get at least one story about a dog or cat that found its way home after being left or lost some distance away. My assistant Jill reports that once when her family was moving to a new house about three miles from the old one she put the family cat in a box in the car, only to have it escape when they arrived. Two days later, when the family drove back to the old house, the cat was sitting on the lawn.

British biologist Rupert Sheldrake, author of Dogs That Know When Their Owners Are Coming Home, and Other Unexplained Powers of Animals (1999), has compiled a database of similar stories--29 homing cats and 60 homing dogs. In most cases the pet was transported from its home to an unfamiliar location without having a chance to learn the smells or landmarks en route, and typically it followed a different route home. Sheldrake doesn't state the average length of the journey or how well the animals knew their environs previously, but he does tell of dogs used in cattle drives that were sent home on their own and traveled 100 miles, admittedly over a familiar route. On the other hand, in experiments conducted by himself or others, the distance is usually much less--six miles, five miles, three miles. Not all animals have the gift; some dogs, left on their own, head in the wrong direction or park themselves on the nearest doorstep and look forlorn.

The homing champs are undoubtedly birds. The navigational abilities of homing pigeons are well known. Even more impressive are those of sea birds such as the albatross, which can fly home from as much as 4,000 miles away. Monarch butterflies, Sheldrake notes, annually migrate 2,000 miles from the Great Lakes to Mexico and back. Individual butterflies don't live long enough to make the round trip, but somehow the species as a whole knows which Mexican "butterfly trees" to return to every winter, even though three to five generations may intervene between one visit and the next.

How do they do it? Sheldrake contends that the question has utterly defeated scientists and proposes a bizarre theory about "morphic fields" that says the laws of nature aren't really laws, they're just habits, and that animals navigate in part by tapping into the collective memory of their species. (If you're interested in this kind of thing, visit his Web site at www.sheldrake.org.)

But the mystery may not be as impenetrable as he makes out. In reviewing research on pigeons, for example, he notes that numerous possible orienting methodologies have been ruled out--the sun (pigeons can find their way home on cloudy days), the earth's magnetic field (pigeons aren't thrown off if a magnet is strapped to them), and so on. Apparently Sheldrake assumes that the birds navigate by a single mechanism, but it seems more likely that they have multiple means of finding their way and fall back on Plan B if Plan A doesn't work. Similarly, the ability of dogs and cats to find their way home doesn't seem all that miraculous. Sheldrake's own research, in which he let a dog loose several miles from home, then tracked its location using the satellite-based global positioning system, suggests that the dog just wandered around till it found a familiar landmark.

Still, there's plenty about animals we just don't know. As the title of Sheldrake's book suggests, dogs often have an uncanny ability to anticipate their owners' arrival. Jill reports that when she was a child, her dog Louie was in the habit of meeting her at the bus stop after school. One morning her mom chided the dog for heading out several hours early, but it turned out Jill had left school several hours early too--and there was Louie, waiting to meet her. Morphic resonance? ESP? Lucky coincidence? Beats me. But there may be more going on behind those big brown eyes (Louie's, I mean) than we understand.

Once I caught a squirrel in a Hav-a-Hart trap and took him two miles away and three days later I thought that the same squirrel had made it back (he had a big chunck of tail hair out).

I caught him again (they can't resist peanut butter) in the trap and sprayed a little flouresent paint on his tail, them took him 10 miles and over one very large highway (Ga 400 for you North Ga types) on my way to work. I kid you not he came back although it took two weeks.

So the next time my wife went to the grocery store, I shot him and threw him over the backyard fence.

That pretty much took care of it because he hasn't come back yet.

By the way the best squirrel-free feeder is the Yankee Flipper. Spins em right off.

I would like to know how my hummingbirds make it back every year. Come a certain day in May, and it varies a little bit from year to year, they come and tap at my window if I haven't put their feeder out.

I am in upstate NY, and I know they migrate down to Florida and across the Gulf of Mexico, so can't figure out how they wing their little way back to my particular patio to tell me to hustle up and boil their sugar water!

And, God help me if I haven't purchased their favorite hanging plant and put it out for them! Gotta get a red fuschia in a hanging pot, or they hand around and scold me.

Anyone know how these tiny little creatures manage all that?

Sheldrake is a former director of studies for cellular biology at Cambridge who has adapted statistical methodologies and intelligent experimental design to the study of things normally categorized as paranormal; he's one of the brighter people I'ver ever come into contact with. His book "Seven Experiments Which Could Change the World" can be found in paperback at most outlets, and is worth reading.

A story, it's not really incredible but it's a true example of what a dog I had did.

When I was a kid our family had a nice little cocker-heinz 57 mix. My brother and I played Little League Ball, one day my Dad took the dog to watch us play at the field across town about 3 miles away. Somehow the pooch wandered away and we couldn't find her, we looked and looked, finally it was getting dark and we had to quit. We were crying and all the stuff 12 year olds do as my Dad drove us home without our "Pepper".

The next morning to our surprise she was waiting on our porch happy to see us. What relief.

She managed to find her way home from a place about 3 miles away that she never walked to herself. My brother and I did walk there but not that often. We figured she caught our tracks or maybe she knew the smell of our area of town and followed that. Who knows how she found her way home but we were happy that she did.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.