If “real” conservatives showed out in record numbers, as you claim, who were the missing voters?
The numbers for Evangelical voters are well researched.
Overall turnout out in 2012 was about a million more Republican voters than in 2008.
The problem is that you can’t just run anyone you guys want and win elections, and berating conservatives for not liking your guy indicates that you want to just keep demanding that everyone get in line with your politics, rather than look at what you are doing wrong, or that your politics might be wrong.
Social liberalism is wrong.