[sinkspur]

John, you have no answer for this woman, do you? (Platitudes are not an answer).

[Antoninus]

John, you have no answer for this woman, do you? (Platitudes are not an answer).

Your "answer" is to tell her it's ok to commit a mortal sin. Some answer. The wages of sin are death.

The only correct answer to this problem is abstinence and cultural change. Any other "answer", such as the one you propose, will result in more death, and more suffering in both the short and long term.

This whole issue is like the "cases of rape and incest" arguments for abortion. The proponents create "worst case scenarios" to get the nose of the camel under the tent. We know what happens from there.