A couple of the best religion professors at Wake Forest (from my time there in the 1970's) have moved to Baylor - both top-flight academics and professing classical Christians, but certainly not fundamentalists.
Baylor is almost as removed from a Christian view as Wake Forest is from Southeastern Seminary (origional WFU campus); about 100 miles and 100 years. My pastor's btother was up for the Chancellor's job years ago and could not get it because his brother was too conservative.
They will be as Christian as Harvard is from its roots today. Hey! I'm WFU; a Double-Deacon from Wake MBA.