[anonymous_user]

Note: analogies work as argumentation only when they actually parallel the situation actually under discussion. Otherwise they are just hot air.

Note, yourself. You're the one who's pushing free recordings as a formula for better music and a better business model. Who's full of hot air?

[John Valentine]

You're the one who's pushing free recordings as a formula for better music and a better business model.

Never said that. Please don't put words in my mouth. That's dishonest, and I resent it.

All I am saying and all I have ever said is that the industry has not been hurt, is not being hurt, and is most likely helped by peer sharing as it exists today.