Every review I have heard ir read says this is one of the best Star Wars ever. Not one person has said its bad, I understand Hayden Christenson acting still sucks though.
I cry at the drop of a hat but wouldn't even be tempted by a star wars movie.
Considering that he's the main character, the fact that he's still there, not acting, is most disturbing. Who the hell was the casting genius who hired that lightweight?
As for the movie, I heard that Ian McDiarmid is deliciously good as Palpatine so it's probably still worth seeing.
It "feels" big, but one hour after watching it, you find it has all floated away. It is the Chinese food of movies. Well, that and swiss cheese - lots of plot holes that leave one really unsatisfied afterwards. It is not bad only because its sibling movies in the "Star Wars" saga have already lowered expectations.