[Protagoras]

"Individuals have no 'fundamental' constitutional right to smoke tobacco," the judge wrote.

And the judge has no fundamental understanding of the constitution, much less rights.

This is past sad.

[Gabz]

Setting aside the issue of wheteher one has the right to smoke or not for a moment - what about the "rights" of a PRIVATE club on private property?

I agree with your conclusion regarding said judge.