My brother's children do better, especially socially, homeschooling. My daughter, on the other hand, does much better in school.
We have friends who homeschooled their daughter all the way through school, and yes, she is different, but remarkable. She doesn't care about peer pressure, she has a strong moral sense and work ethic. She is 19 and teaches textile art classes, has art shows, and works at cultural events. She also sells her work, and does quite well, I think.
I think it all depends on the child. The parents of the aforementioned girl would disagree with me, but I don't think everyone (especially me) is good at homeschooling.
You were probably better than you thought!!!!!!!!!!!