Posted on 01/04/2006 3:57:30 AM PST by Erik Latranyi
I sent a email..
Please add incorrect and dubious statements by corporate officials - who frankly after they've had a few drinks will admit that they don't give a crap - vis-a-vis this:
TALLMANSVILLE, West Virginia -- Grief and anger replaced jubilation early Wednesday as mine officials announced that, despite earlier reports, only one of 13 trapped miners had survived a West Virginia mining accident.
Late Tuesday, celebrations erupted as word spread among family members that 12 miners had been found alive at the Sago Mine.
Hours later, Ben Hatfield, president and CEO of the mine company, told miners' loved ones that a "miscommunication" had resulted in an error: all but one of the missing miners was dead.
On reviewing the main thread, during the period between the reports they were alive and the report that they were dead, there were actually people on it happily gloating that the families in the church celebrating DIDN'T get the good news from the media but from other sources.
I give the media no slack- yet think of this. Reporters standing in front of the church..hearing the church bells ringing and watching families come out shouting with joy.."They're alive". Reporters know the families are briefed first- it would be weird if they DIDN'T report what they were SEEING.
What's pretty hard to grasp- is how this error could have been perpetrated for 3 hours. At SOME point- didn't it occur to someone- reporter- to get this info confirmed?
I applaud Hemmer simply because he took responsibility- and actually said he was ashamed. It was clearly a reflective moment- he was thinking out loud-if you will- saying how awful he felt being a part of leading the families on.
"On reviewing the main thread, during the period between the reports they were alive and the report that they were dead, there were actually people on it happily gloating that the families in the church celebrating DIDN'T get the good news from the media but from other sources."
Exactly!
To hang the media alone on this is just a irresponsable as the false story. It was a mistake in communication and the media had no choice, but to report what was told to the church. How could the media not report what was happening right there in front of them?
Their first clue should have been that there was NO press release from the mine officials. Didn't they suspect that was odd? Why didn't anyone question why they had heard nothing official?
As the celebrating began, Geraldo showed up!!!!
Do we know really that no one died in the time from when they were found to when they were brought out of the mine?
Fox link is down right now. But I would be grateful if someone could clear this up for me.
The response I usually hear is "well, that's different."
I also find it difficult to believe that the fairly significant number of people on FR who were going beyond merely "Thank God" to "Hah Hah! This will show nonbelievers the power of prayer and that God exists!", if they had been in the media and outside the celebrating church, would have suddenly turned into Mr. Reporter Skeptic and been trying to downplay reports of the survival of the miners.
"Swarthy men of middle eastern extraction in running suits have been seen fleeing from the area of the Edward P. Murrah Federal building explosion!"
What appears to have happened is that some reporters were hanging around the command center and overheard the radio communications with the rescue workers.
The rescue workers reported that "we found them", but nothing about their condition. The reporters ran with it from that point that the miners were found alive.
My guess which is as good as anyones right now, is that someone thought they heard they are checking THE vital signs when what they said we are checking FOR vital signs.
I know that's what you want to believe but I really don't see much evidence of the above; if you go back and read the main thread it seems clear that the first indication the media had they were alive was the celebration in the church. The origin of the story was completely independent of the media. The people in the church didn't find out the miners were "alive" from the media.
News gathering is not a perfect science. And sometimes, the media is given dis-information from multiple sources in order to divert their trail.
I'm not an apologist for the media. But we have been conditioned, especially by the right, to rail against the media for all of what ails us.
I listened for an agonizing week to Air America. Funny, but one of their complaints was that the media was not accurately reporting.
The governor annouced nothing. All he said was he was going to check it out.
Mine officials never announced that they were found alive. That is why the media kept running the disclaimer that it was "unconfirmed reports" because nobody in an official capacity would confirm the story.
Sorry, but this is a media creation of running with rumor and unsubstantiated information.
Yeah it's all about you, you SOB.
You do understand the celebration of the families in the church was not based on media info, right?
The governor was in the church with the families when they started cheering. He asked them what was happening and they reported it to him. On his way to the command center to confirm the story, reporters stuck microphones in his face to get a soundbite.
Don't blame the governor. Don't blame mine officials. This is purely a media-created story due to rumor and unsubstantiated information.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.