When we "don't give a damn" the results that accrue are results we agree with, by default, because "we don't give a damn".
All criminals deserve just punishment and I have no sympathy for complaints against a just punishment. Rape is not a just punishment. I cannot condone it or stand back and not complain about it nor stand lacking in sympathy and compassion for those abused by rape in prison. Maybe you believe rape is their due just because they are in prison. I do not find anything rational, conservative or moral in that position.