To: blam
interesting. there's evidence both ways, but the salt hypothesis seems more likely. I'm no expert, but I'm considering getting a geology degree (and do have some real knowledge) and for what it's worth, a basin related to salt flow is exactly what popped into mind after reading 7 words into the article, to North Sea.
2 posted on
03/30/2007 3:17:06 PM PDT by
verum ago
(The Iranian Space Agency: set phasers to jihad!)
To: verum ago
Would not some cores of the crater add more information? The presence of minerals known to be created in cosmic impacts would seem to confirm the impact theory, but the lack of minerals couldn't discount it, either, current erosion and all that.
To: verum ago
yes- cores of the crater would make or break the impact hypothesis very easily- since the site is under water and has in fact had further sediments deposited onto it, the original mineralogy of the sea-bottom crater should be intact. Even if it was destroyed, then there should still be distinctive 'shocked' mineral crystals in the bedrock underlaying the crater.(this is one of the nicer features of large impacts- they leave behind evidence in the nearby bedrock that wasn't macroscopically deformed, meaning that even if the entire crater structure (surface and subsurface) was erased there could still be evidence of the impact. of course, without the crater structures no one would look for these signs)
the problems here are that the geometry of the basin suggest an impact (as does the 'nipple' structure), but such extensive and symmetric concentric rings haven't been observed except on icy bodies elsewhere in the solar system- where the topmost layer is the most rigid and the ones beneath are more plastic or even fluid- it should be the opposite on earth. Of course no salt recession basin has ever been seen with so perfect geometry, but if it's true that the area is littered with similar features and that they correspond with thinning in the salt layer the salt theory would be a lot stronger. The fact is that the multitude of rings actually is a bit problematic for both hypotheses- it could theoretically be possible for both, but has never been observed under the circumstances for either.
4 posted on
03/30/2007 4:07:56 PM PDT by
verum ago
(The Iranian Space Agency: set phasers to jihad!)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson