You’ve not mentioned on this thread, and I think it is a valid question, how many of the HP books have you read? You have strongly held convictions about the books, so I have to assume that you are speaking from your personal experience after having read one or more of the series in its entirety.
You certainly wouldn’t be talking about the details of books based solely on what you’ve heard from others, would you?
“You’ve not mentioned on this thread, and I think it is a valid question, how many of the HP books have you read? “
I’ve seen all the movies.