Posted on 09/17/2007 9:04:58 PM PDT by jazusamo
In a world where the tragedy that is Iraq is usually discussed only in media sound bites and political slogans, it is especially gratifying to see an adult, intelligent, and insightful account of life inside Iraq by someone who lived there for nine months in the early days of the occupation in 2003 and 2004, and who saw the fundamental mistakes that would later plague the attempt to create a viable Iraqi government.
John Agresto, a career American academic and former college president who volunteered to go help create a better higher education system in Iraq, learned a lot about Iraqi society in general and about American attempts to create a better society there.
His recently published book is titled "Mugged by Reality" and is subtitled: "The Liberation of Iraq and the Failure of Good Intentions."
What is refreshingly different about this book is that it does not take the Bush administration line, the Congressional Democrats' line or anybody else's line.
Agresto is not out to prove some theory or push some pet scheme but to convey what he saw with his own eyes and discerned from his own experiences with both Iraqis and Americans in Iraq.
He makes no claim to infallibility but in fact admits to being forced to change his mind by what he saw.
Initially a supporter of the invasion, he now says that he would not have been a supporter if he had known beforehand how the occupation would be mishandled and the results that followed. But he also recognizes that we cannot unring the bell and simply leave, for that would lead to even worse consequences, not only in Iraq but elsewhere, not only to others but to ourselves.
The worst mistake, in Agresto's view, was the failure to establish law and order in the wake of the military victory, before undertaking the grandiose project of attempting to create democracy in Iraq. From this fundamental mistake, many of the other tragedies followed.
In the absence of law and order, there was widespread violence, looting, rape — in short, the war of each against all that Hobbes warned about, centuries ago.
As for democracy, Agresto understands that the right to vote is no guarantee of freedom, toleration or respect for the rights of others. Without those prerequisites, democracy can mean tyranny at home and terrorism abroad.
Apparently the American civilian authorities in Iraq did not understand this or else they let that understanding be overridden by political considerations. By setting up a government based on warring factions, they made cooperation in the national interest a very unlikely prospect.
Today, when more and more Iraqis are rejecting the outside terrorists whom the media keep calling "insurgents," and when our military is restoring more order than Iraq has seen in a while, the most intractable problem is the very government we set up.
General David Petraeus is mentioned only a couple of times, and briefly, in "Mugged by Reality." But those brief mentions seem to be revealing.
Right after the success of military operations in Iraq, General Petraeus' 101st Airborne had control of the city of Mosul. According to Agresto, "he ran it in radically different ways than the rest of Iraq was run" — and Mosul was "calm" in contrast to other parts of Iraq.
Then, after control of Mosul was passed on to others, it "began to rival the worst sections of Baghdad for attacks on Coalition forces and violence against Iraqis."
One of the ways in which Petraeus ran Mosul differently from the way things were done in the rest of Iraq, according to Agresto, was not to get rid of existing public officials wholesale, despite their being members of the former ruling Baath Party.
Somebody has to run the basic institutions that make civilized life possible — and you can't just get rid of those who know how to run those institutions before you have someone qualified to replace them. Apparently General Petraeus was pragmatic enough to understand that.
We may, belatedly, have found a man and an approach that work.
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institute and author of Basic Economics: A Citizen's Guide to the Economy.
no doubt many will attack you for this post.
Let them attack away, I believe Dr. Sowell makes some good points.
Yes he did; he always, always does.
As per usual, a very thougtful article by the Doctor.
I always enjoy reading his thoughts; he’s right pretty much all the time.
Thomas Sowell is the second person in a week I know of to recommend this book. My interest is piqued.
Rings true.
thanks for posting this ...
I’m always troubled with the “we made mistakes and the suffering was “ comments.....sorry , but I am....
This decision to war in Iraq and Afghanistan was set in stone when two skyscrapers were brought to rubble.
We didn’t do it and the it never happened on American soil before.
Those that did it live in holes like badgers and under rocks like snakes
The worst part is these bastards of religion and God given rights kill in the name of ALLAH.
What we are doing is right,where we are doing it is right and why we are doing it is right. To not,is death,praise be Allah...........Allah,my ass.
Not I. Thomas Sowell's articles are always thought provoking and a great read.
There happens to be classified intelligence on Iraq & Libya and several other countries of evidence that they were part of 911. The leader of Iraq HAD to be taken OUT...the aftermath has been handled poorly until recently....those are the facts...
Where I've been in disagreement is...with handing over Iraq to the Iraqi people way to soon, they've not been capable in running their country. We've seen that for ourselves.
This is the first I’ve heard of John Agresto but if Dr. Sowell speaks well of him I’m interested in his book.
same kind of thing Patton got in trouble for after the defeat of Nazi Germany...
How the F' we're we supposed to pull this one off????
What little I know of combat and combat leadership (from watching TV) is that the best decisions made with all available information are often wrong (or at least can be perceived as such) and the most hastily, ill informed decisions can look like masterstrokes of genius.
American society needs to learn the meaning of being men, that is learning to make decisions they can live with, and living with the decisions made.
Hand wringing and Self-Analysis ain't something you do in a mortal fight. Academics make me puke.
I have to give her credit if I know what's good for me.
Well said and what Sowell pointed out about Petraeus running Mosul earlier jives with what I’ve read in the past.
I am firm in that belief, and therefore, have no problems with someone saying mistakes were made.
Mistakes are made in every war, in every peace, in every country, by everybody, etc.
I'm supporting Gen. P's efforts, even though I'm sure that someone, somewhere will be able to point out that he is making some "mistakes" (which sometimes are only in the eye of the beholder, with 20/20 hindsight).
I agree with you, fight and kill them there, which Gen. P's troops seem to be doing quite well right now.
,
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.