In 2004 Catholics went 52% to 47% for Bush.
In 2008 white Catholics went for McCain 52% to 41%.
41% should be 47%
Right, in his reelection Bush won 52% of the Catholic vote, but not in 2000, and Bush won 56% of the Protestant Hispanic vote in that 2004 reelection race.
In the 2008 election you break out the White only vote, which doesn’t change the point, Catholics voted for Obama.