[DTogo]

As Solicitor General under Obama, will Kagan have to recuse herself... ensuring this ruling is upheld?!

[backwoods-engineer]

Kagan didn’t recuse herself last time a case came up in which she had been Sol General... so why should she now? She is there, like Sotomayor, to overturn the Constitution, plain and simple.

[NRG1973]

As Solicitor General under Obama, will Kagan have to recuse herself... ensuring this ruling is upheld?!

If its true that Kagan must recuse herself (and I doubt that because she never got involved with this case/issue as Solicitor General) Then a 4-4 decision would uphold the allelate court ruling. Thus, I hope that the appelate court does uphold Hudson's ruling.