[rxsid]

Check my profile.

I'm on record for a LONG time stating that the SCOTUS cases I cite, mention born in soverign territory to citizen parentS in the dicta.

You, on the other hand, tried to pass off the dicta of a state court case as having found someone born in N.Y. to foreign parents as being NBC...

"Lynch was found to be a natural born citizen.
...
1,251 posted on Wednesday, April 27, 2011 3:31:35 PM by Mr Rogers"

When in fact, they did no such thing. The ruling of the court was that she was a "citizen."

 

You blatently lied.

You don't do yourself a favor regurgitating the crap from OBOT sites like Dr. Conspiracy's

[Mr Rogers]

You quote dicta, and so do I. The difference is you quote it out of context.

“You don’t do yourself a favor regurgitating the crap from OBOT sites like Dr. Conspiracy’s”

If Mario Apuzzo can post and debate on Dr Conspiracy - and do so with courtesy and honesty - then perhaps you could learn something there. And the only thing I’ve used that site for was a picture of the 1787 American translation of Vattel - which Dr Conspiracy got from a friend of Mario Apuzzo. If you haven’t heard of him, try reading here:

http://puzo1.blogspot.com/