Here is the writer’s own view of what got us out of the depression:
On the surface, wartime spending finally propelled America from the Depressions pits. As war production expanded from roughly 2% of GDP to almost 40%, statistically, America rebounded. In 1940 dollars, GDP shot from $101.4 billion to $120.7 billion in 1941 up to $174.8 billion by 1945 while unemployment fell below 2%.
America didnt officially enter the fray until December 1941. FDR had by then rescinded most New Deal regulations, scuttled the WPA and similar agencies and ceased his incessant public bickering with private business. Some surmise he stopped attacking industry recognizing he needed their help attacking fascism.
The pre Pearl Harbor boost stems from three factors: wartime spending by others, which does not reflect stimulus on Washingtons part; Lend-Lease, but giving away munitions abroad promotes no prosperity here, and the demise of the New Deal.
After netting out federal spending, GDP surged 17% from $91.9 billion in 1940 to $107.7 billion in 1941. Once engaged, our non-federal output trickled down to $101.4 billion by WWIIs conclusion in 1945.
The private economy reflected little improvement, partly because private consumption was curbed. Living standards didnt regain 1929 levels until America restored a market based economy in the aftermath of victory.
The president proposed a Bill of Economic Rights predicated on aggregate demand maintenance. Congress thankfully repudiated it. Tax rates were slashed while war time rationing, price controls and regulations receded.
America was one of few industrial nations with its productive infrastructure intact. Despite federal spending falling from $93 billion in 1945 to under $30 billion by 1948 (in 1945 dollars), unemployment stabilized around 4% as Americans, free of New Deal shackles, launched an economic boom.
How does blowing up Germany boost American living standards? How is making men sleep in frigid fox holes under enemy fire enriching? How did rationing everything from the enjoyment of luxuries to our clothing and diets lift anyones material standing?
The military doesnt jumpstart the economy, it protects producers. This represents patriotic sacrifice, not prosperity.
Production is the progenitor of wealth, but making things unvalued by markets doesnt improve life. Neither does working harder to achieve the same result. Repairing damage caused by war or natural calamity through debt encumbrance does nothing to support sustainable growth. Once said project completes, were back where we started with debts to boot.
Well, two out of three ain't bad. I overlooked "the demise of the New Deal" -- but incorporated deregulation in the prescription for ending our economic woes today.