Posted on 10/14/2011 6:09:29 PM PDT by Hojczyk
I think “Patton” was probably the best war movie I have ever seen. I had read a couple of books about him and the movie was surprisingly reliable.
It was also good entertainment.
The first time I saw “Tora Tora Tora” it was really disappointing. Seeing it a couple of more times it got better. Same for “Midway”.
A real disappointment was “MacArthur”.
It’s been years since I’ve gone to the movies but we went to see Courageous last week. They had the trailer for Act of Valor. I’m going to make a point to see this.
Not a bad movie...but “Patton” is still the best in my opinion
I give “Black Hawk Down” a big thumbs up for being a great war movie. “Saving Private Ryan” was good as well. The series “Band of Brothers” was fantastic.
Kelly’s Heros. Going at the krauts old school.
Band of Brothers
To me, the best war movie ever made.
Another good one was “Sgt. York”. Absolutely loved Walter Brennan as Pastor Pyle.
No one else could have jumped and danced around singing “Give me that old time Religion” without looking weird. Brennan simply made me want to do the same thing.
Except for the voice http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QXzT_j8NZsg&feature=related
Well the tanks were wrong too but it would have probably been impossible to find dozens of Shermans and Panthers to make a movie.
Patton was no doubt an outstanding movie. One that makes you proud to be an American.
However, on the subject of war, I prefer to watch it through the perspective of the subordinates rather than the officers. I don’t like tidy movies where everything makes sense either.
For those reasons, I give the nod to Das Boot as the greatest war movie ever made.
Hell, All Commando Baracko has to do is star in one more blockbuster like this and he can retire the national debt all by himself...
Das Boot was really depressing to me. Of course being on one of those U-boats especially late in the war would have been awfully tough. Their losses were extreme.
I personally think the soldiers who most unappreciated are the combat engineers. They were the first to land at Normandy and suffered 80 percent casualties. They had to clear obstructions to the landing craft. We would never landed without them.
In the Battle of the Bulge, the combat engineers were the last ditch forces left to defend then destroy bridges.
The leader of the tanks which were to break through to Antwerp said “ those damned engineers stopped us by blowing bridges and fuel dumps just as we got to them.
“All Quiet on the Western Front”
The original.
Groan. Tanks have to be the worst part of WWII movies. Operational Shermans and T-34's were still to be found in the 1970's although they were seldom used. Only recently have enough Panthers, Tigers and Jagdpanzers been pulled from Eastern European bogs, lake bottoms and river bottoms and restored to operational condition that realistic WWII movies are possible..
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.